Saturday, November 21, 2009

Some Odds and Ends

I am happy to announce that sometime close to the end of October, Fantasy Book Critic had its 1000 post in its 2 2/3 years since its first post in March 2007.

A quick estimate using the Index statistics from the front page and about 70% if not more of the posts are original content: reviews, interviews, essays, best of, monthly spotlights, author posts, with the rest mostly giveaways and news capsules.

We hope to continue posting lots of original content and keeping the pace of one such post per day at least in the weekdays, and hopefully then in the weekends, but we would like also to remind everyone that Fantasy Book Critic is something we do in our free time, while we receive arcs of many books, we also acquire a lot of books talked about here independently - mostly bought of course, with some from libraries or friends - and we are not paid by anyone otherwise, so if "real life" intervenes, it takes priority. Luckily, at least so far there was always someone to keep the site going and we hope this will be case for a long time to come. We (Cindy, Robert, Liviu, Mihir, Fabio) are here and we plan to keep talking about the books that interest us.

**************************************


Our friend Jeff from Fantasy Book News & Reviews wants help with an Amazon ebook experiment, namely requesting two books from Tad Williams to be available on the Kindle. Since this is a cause dear to me also and since on general principles I request any book of interest to me on the Kindle also, I think it is a good idea to participate. Unfortunately this is possible only from people based in the US since as opposed to print books, ebooks have geographical restrictions.

*************************************

Recently there have been some heated discussion (here, here, here just for a start with lots of comments from people involved too) about fantasy covers and in one case even about a change in title from UK to US publication. Some of the covers involved are presented below (all corresponding book editions are tbp 2010) :



mmpb edition of the superb Nights of Villjamur/Mark C. Newton
new and highly awaited Brent Weeks' novel Black Prism
very intriguing Pyr debut Shadow's Sun by Jon Sprunk
US edition with changed name of Robert Redick's excellent "Rats and the Ruling Sea"
highly anticipated Strahan
/Anders anthology "Swords and Dark Magic"


I did a post on covers sometime ago discussing how they influenced or not my perception of the books in cause, with some concrete examples of books for which the cover was essential in finding them. Since the discussion which starts in the links above covers many points of view, the only thing I would add is that in discussing covers one thing that is sometimes forgotten is the sheer number of books published all the time, from new books, to new formats to reprints.

This huge number means that outside a (very) few "everyone has heard of" books, the rest have to fiercely compete for readers' attention, so if it means having a hooded figure, or a swordsman/woman in order to attract the people who love epic fantasy but are not "online hardcore readers" like us, so be it.

Friday, November 20, 2009

The Ambergris Week - Part 3: Finch



Behold the birth (and the death) of sporepunk. If Jeff VanderMeer´s FINCH could be summated in but one word (it can´t, mind you, but let´s pretend, just for argument´s sake), it could be this one: sporepunk.

Naturally, the suffix punk is more than overrated, and the story doesn´t have anything to do with old cyberpunk or steampunk stories. It is, however, a good, old-fashioned (or should we say new-fashioned?) noir mystery, with lots of biotechnology in a post-apocaliptic setting. This is what the third and last Ambergris story is about.

Forget the baroque language here, kiddo. What´s the angle? We´re talking about going to dark places, not the dark places of the mind, but to very real dark corners, amidst the debris of the Rising, the period six years before the story when the gray caps finally took over Ambergris and dominated the city, making no prisioners but instead co-opting them - offering some of them a kind of twisted fungal post-humanity (being the case of the hybrid Partials, virtual recording machines with sporetech implants) or just making them as their working force. That is the case of detective John Finch, who must solve a double murder where - obviously - nothing is what it looks like, and every little step he takes can get him in the path (and in the wrath) of the Insurgents, led by the insidious and invisible Lady in Blue...

This story is set after the events of Shriek - apparently far in the future, but how far we can´t be sure; the city of Ambergris was completely taken by the gray caps, who rule the city not exactly with an iron hand, but with a cruel pervasiveness - and a strange spore-based technology which infiltrates in human systems and destroys them slowly - as it´s been doing with Wyte, partner of detective John Finch. Finch, a cynical, sad man reminiscent of Raymond Chandler´s Philip Marlowe (but imagine a Marlowe aged beyond his years, too exhausted to be a smart-alec), has himself his share of skeletons in the closet, and, in the space of a few days, must fend off attackers of all kinds and solve this nagging mystery. He also must try to survive - but who wouldn´t, in a place like Ambergris-in-ruins?

Finch reminded me of David Cronenberg´s eXistenZ and its ugly, weird organic weaponry. The more-or-less Burroughs-like "soft machines" that are the gray caps´s guns, of spongy texture and which more often than not kill by contagious instead of simple hard impact, provides the narrative with an almost palpable texture. FINCH is a tactile novel.

The narrative here is really weird. Think of Dashiell Hammett (or Ross MacDonald, for that matter) meets Lovecraft - with more narrative focus and cutting all the adverbs. Michael Moorcock also comes to mind in several parts of the narrative, for reasons which, if explained, can easily turn into spoilers, so they won´t be described here. All you must know is that Finch, as a narrative experience, is entirely different from VanderMeer´s previous Ambergris books. It´s gritty, strong reading, and highly rewarding as such.

The story is sad in its end, and in its sense of finality. When we get closer to the book´s ending and we slowly become aware that there will be no more Ambergris stories (paraphrasing Paul Éluard, there may be, but in other worlds), we feel awful. we feel like crying. As if we had lost an old friend. Like Ambergris.

This is the last transmission of this insurgent cell (for now, at least). Thank you for staying with us until the end of this long week. Long live Ambergris.

(This review was first posted in Post-Weird Thoughts)

Thursday, November 19, 2009

Liviu's Top Novels of the 00's Decade

Inspired by this sffworld thread I decided to do a post with my choices considering that it is mid-November 09. As usual I separate the novels in categories, this time just three: mainstream, fantasy and sf.

**********************************

Mainstream:

1. Les Bienveillantes/The Kindly Ones - Jonathan Littell (French 2006, Engl 2009)
- memoirs of fictional SS officer Dr. Maxiliam Aue; evil that will fascinate and maybe even insidiously seduce you; page turner, engrossing, dark, horrifying at times, with passages that will make you cry.
(
FBC Capsule Rv - this one I should extend into a full review sometime)

2. 2666 - Roberto Bolano (Spanish 2006, Engl 2008)
-mosaic novel in 5 interconnected parts about a mysterious German writer, serial murders in a Mexican town and much, much more; funny, then dark, then ultra-dark and then back to lighter, more adventurous stuff; published posthumously and with an unfinished feel, a sixth part has been found and will be published soon.
(FBC Rv tbp sometime)


3. The Dream of Scipio - Iain Pears (2002)
-this one has an opening page that is for the ages - Amazon inside has it HERE; love, destiny, historical responsibility in the context of turbulent eras in Provence of the late 400's and the barbarian invasions, the mid 1300's and the Black Death and the 1940's and the Nazi occupation - 3 men, 3 women, intertwined stories.
(
FBC Rv of Stone's Fall by I. Pears)

4. Europe Central - William Vollmann (2005)
-the largest and most devastating land war in history, the 1941-1945 one between Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia in 800 dense pages of vignettes; Shostakovich and Akhmatova are among the main protagonists and the novel extends to the 60's as well as starting in 1918; brilliant but very hard.

5-tie The Blind Assassin - Margaret Atwood (2000)
- another novel that starts with the dramatic ending like The Dream of Scipio and unravels the story on the way, this one is just superb; two sisters, two men and many secrets; also an epic tale of Canada from the 1910's to the 1940's with vignettes from the present.
(
FBC Rv of The Year of the Flood by M. Atwood)

5-tie Cloud Atlas - David Mitchell (2004)
- a six part novel, each part divided into two and connected with the next, with the first half chronological, the second half inverse chronological, so the middle of the novel is the whole sixth tale; tour de force combining historical fiction with contemporary noir/horror and with sfnal dystopia.

5-tie The Vengeance of Rome - Michael Moorcock (2006)
- the ending of the Colonel Pyat saga; another memoir of an evil man, but this time he is small potatoes compared with Dr. Aue as actual rather than imagined actions; Pyat is a buffoon to boot, though he still manages to thoroughly disgust but also fascinate the reader; also like The Kindly Ones the novel contains graphic stuff that is definitely not for everyone

*******************************


Fantasy:

1. The Scar - China Mieville (2002)
- a masterpiece of sff, inventive and absorbing; second in the loosely linked New Crobuzon novels, it leaves more mysteries than it solves so I am still hoping for a sequel-like novel .
(FBC RV of the author's City and the City HERE and HERE
)

2. Kushiel's Dart - Jacqueline Carey (2001)
-the beginning of the most beguiling and fascinating fantasy universe - it's actually an alt-Earth one - the whole series standing at 6 novels and now continued some hundred years later in a new series is just a treat.
(FBC Rv of Kushiel's Justice #5, Kushiel's Mercy #6 and Naamah's Kiss #1 in the new series; FBC Interview with J. Carey)


3. The Darkness That Came Before - Scott Bakker (2004)
- the beginning of the superb Prince of Nothing trilogy; some of the most fascinating characters in fantasy in Kelhus, Cnaiur, Achamanian; also the best original (ie no pseudo-medieval) world building in fantasy.
(FBC Rv of Judging Eye the promising but more introductory than anything else start of the follow up series to PoN; FBC Rv of Neuropath)


4. Before They Are Hanged - Joe Abercrombie (2007)
-intrigue, great characters and superb plotting make this second installment in the First Law trilogy a novel to remember; it also ties perfectly with the standalone Best Served Cold.
(FBC Rv of The Blade Itself, FBC Rv of Before They Are Hanged by Robert Thompson who disagreed somewhat with me here, FBC Rv of Best Served Cold; FBC Interview with J. Abercrombie)


5. Storm of Swords - George RR Martin (2000)
-while powerful, I liked this novel less than the first two in the series; I thought that it was too sprawling and that the series is losing focus here so despite some great scenes, the whole is less than the sum of its parts; still a superb novel overall.
(FBC Rv of co-authored Hunter's Run)


*******************************


SF:

1. Anathem - Neal Stephenson (2008)
-masterpiece of sff and a once in a decade novel - I reviewed it fully HERE.

2. Pandora's Star - Peter Hamilton (2004)
-excellent start to the Commonwealth series; trains in space, great characters and everything that made PFH the "king of space opera"; the sequel Judas Unchained did not quite live up to my ultra-high expectations so the series overall is below the superb and still my #1 finished sff series of all time Night's Dawn; continued in the Void trilogy of which the first two volumes have been published.
(FBC Rv of Void 1, FBC Rv of Void 2)


3. At All Costs - David Weber (2005)
-the best large scale Honorverse novel and self-contained in so far that is possible in a 19 books and counting saga; powerful and gut-wrenching with an ending that literally made me cry; the (real, published 1955) children book that's on the cover and that Honor reads to her baby and the rest of the kids at the end became also a favorite.
(FBC Rv of Safehold 2, FBC rv of Safehold 3 by D. Weber; FBC interview with David Weber, Honorverse overview tbp)


4. Stone - Adam Roberts (2002)
-"counter" space opera or maybe space opera reexamined, this is the shortest of all the novels mentioned here and is a must read for anyone that loves that sub-genre; the memoirs of an aberrant genocidal psychopath of indeterminate sex in an Utopian society; or was he/she genocidal??
(FBC Rv of Yellow Blue Tibia by A. Roberts)

5. Omega - Christopher Evans (2008)
- small press novel that is almost perfect in execution; it's of more limited scope than the rest of the sff novels above but it works flawlessly; I reviewed it fully HERE and I wish it will be released in an easily available edition

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

Disruptive Fiction in Group Writing: "Q" by "Luther Blissett" and "Manituana" by "Wu Ming" (Reviewed by Liviu Suciu)



Official "Wu Ming" Website (English)
Download for Free "Q" and "54" (English, Italian and other languages)
Download for Free "Manituana" (Italian only for now)
Order "Q" HERE
Order "Manituana" HERE

Introduction: Some years ago a group of four previously unknown Italian authors rode to bestsellerdom and (group) celebrity by borrowing the name of Luther Blissett, an Italian Serie A player of Afro-Caribbean origins to write a disruptive, uneven in parts but powerful and ultimately superb novel "Q" which is essentially a paean to freedom and the fight against the powerful. Later, the authors renaming themselves "Wu Ming" to avoid controversy, published several more novels, some together like "54" or the recent "Manituana", some individually as Wu Ming 2 or Wu Ming 5.

I have not heard of these books until about a month ago when author Mark C. Newton of the recent excellent major league fantasy debut "Nights of Villjamur" (FBC Rv + Interview) and the upcoming superb sequel "City of Ruin" (read by me as final draft, more about it here closer to pub date, Jun 2010), mentioned them to me and I got intrigued.

Since the Wu Ming foundation graciously made available "Q" free for download in various languages including English, I had it available instantly and I got hooked on opening it, so it became my main fiction read while several days later I got a print copy of "Manituana" (free download Italian only for now) and read it in an evening so absorbing it was; though the denser but "meatier" Q remained with me as one of the best novels I read this year.

Overview/Analysis:
"Q" is narrated by an unnamed freedom fighter and rebel that started as a student of Luther at Wittenberg, but later disgusted by Luther's cozying up to princes and shying away from the revolutionary implications of his rejection of Rome, joined Thomas Muntzer in his 1524-1525 doomed uprising for freedom and equality against the powerful. Surviving the harsh repression, our narrator of many names becomes a "professional" rebel and freedom fighter either directly as in the Munster Anabaptist revolution of 1534-35 or indirectly in subverting the powerful Fuger banking house, preaching Anabaptism in the heartland of Catholicism or sponsoring underground printers of forbidden works.

However, Q a secret agent of the most reactionary Catholic Cardinal Carafa follows our hero's path and we see Q's machinations through his letters addressed to his master which are interspersed with the novel's main narration - though these machinations are not always quite as we expect since Carafa's main interest is preserving the power of Rome which sometimes means allying with the Protestant rebels against the mighty Charles of Spain; the identity of Q is slowly revealed both to us and to our narrator and the final meeting between the two that climaxes the novel is a powerful finale.

Q hooked me from the first page, though it took me a little to get what's what since the narration jumps back and forth in time for the first 100 pages or so. After that it became a page turner that I could not put down to the excellent end. A panoramic novel that deserves all the acclaim it got and more, its strong leftist ethos reminded me powerfully of Howard Fast' Spartacus - the novel better known by its later adaptation in the famous 60's movie - though Q is also a novel of our times in blood, gore, language...

"The powerful is basterds and the basterds become powerful" may be a truism, but through the many adventures of our multi-faceted narrator - who also reminded me strongly of the picaresque anti-heroes of Mika Waltari especially Michael the Finn - we see the illustration of the above principle in blood and violent suppression of the oppressed as well as in the violent reprisals of the leaders of the oppressed when they get to be the basterds...


Highly, highly recommended as a dark, powerful and no-illusions read, you can get a taste of it from the free download linked above!


I was so impressed by Q that I decided to immediately give a try to "Manituana" despite that its subject was of much less interest to me. As the name implies, Manituana follows the tribulations of the Six Nations of the Iroquis and their leader Joseph Brant in what became for them the tragedy of the American Revolution and essentially the death of their nation.

The most powerful Native American
group in the Mohawk River with a constitution hundreds of years old, the Iroquois have coexisted under the protection of the English Crown with the land-hungry colonists for a long time, but now that the protection may be gone when the colonists revolt, their land is in danger to be passed through fire and sword by the rebels.

Joseph Brant a leader of the Iroquois of mixed blood and respected by the English travels to London and to Canada to try save his people, while Washington gives the fatal orders to evict or massacre the Indians.

"Manituana" is very well written and a page turner, but it is even darker than Q and while it is the first of a planned trilogy and ends on a somewhat hopeful note, I was less impressed with it mainly because Joseph Brant is not that a compelling character to make the book stand out in the way the larger than life narrator of Q and the powerful supporting characters do in that novel.
However for a look at the dark side of the American Revolution, including orders of Washington and other leading American generals, "Manituana" holds true to the "disruptive" intent of its authors. I recommend it also and I am interested in the promised sequels

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

"Leviathan" by Scott Westerfeld (Reviewed by Liviu Suciu)


Official Scott Westerfeld Website
Official Leviathan Page with trailer, excerpt, artwork and more
Order Leviathan HERE
See a (superb) Europe Map cca 1914 based on Leviathan


Introduction:
I have read about this book somewhere online some months ago and it strongly intrigued me despite its YA bent. When its trailer linked above appeared, I got hooked and once I read an excerpt and found the prose enjoyable, the book became a buy and read on publication. And I have to say that "Leviathan" delivered all that I expected and more, the only complaint is that I have to wait for the sequel which is now a big asap book of (hopefully) 2010.

Overview/Analysis:
In an alternate Earth cca 1914, where the Great Powers are separated in "Darwinist" and "Clankers" following the "real history" pattern, Charles Darwin discovered both evolution and DNA and he and his disciples learned to splice genes and create astounding animals that are now used in day to day life - will leave to the reader to find out more, but Leviathan of the title is just one of the superb creations of the novel.

On the continent, the German engineers built powerful machines and using the Darwinist inspiration for form and function, they built sort of mechanical analogues - kind of like a steampunk Star Wars kind.

When Franz Ferdinand is assassinated, his 16 year old son Alek becomes a hunted person and he tries to escape in a powerful "walker" with the help of loyal Count Volger and several retainers.

Young Deryn Sharp used to enjoy her "tomboy" life with her father, but when he dies in an accident, she seems destined to a "woman's fate" unless with the help of her older brother Jaspert, junior officer in the Royal Air Force, she will manage to become "Dylan" Sharp and get admitted as a "midshipman".

However at the middy trials, things do not go quite as expected, though "Dylan" keeps "his" head and manages to stay alive in a flying misadventure, only to be rescued over the Channel by Leviathan of the title; since "he" was brave and the rest of the exams are easy with "his" preparation - the flying part has always been the make or break - Dylan remains aboard Leviathan as a middy and later when the ship is sent on a grand mission, Dylan becomes ship guide, cabin "boy" and all around gopher (including "not-quite-dog" walker of pet Tezza) for mysterious scientist Nora Barlow who seems to command a lot of power and influence "despite being a woman".

And so the adventure begins and it's a non-stop page turner to the end, with great inventiveness and superb illustrations that accompany the text. Both main characters are plucky and endearing and their adventures will keep you turning the pages and wish for more. The plot so far is somewhat predictable but the inventiveness of the novel, the superb and clear prose style and of course, "Dylan" and Alek make "Leviathan" one of the best lighter sff novels of the year and one the big positive surprises of the year for me.

In many ways reading like one of the many superb Jules Verne novels that enhanced my childhood, but with prose, sensibilities and "inventions" reflecting our current 21st century, I highly, highly recommend "Leviathan".

Monday, November 16, 2009

"Os Dias Da Peste" FBC's co-editor Fabio Fernandes first novel is published in Brazil




We are thrilled to announce that Fabio Fernandes our colleague here at FBC has just published his first novel in his native Brazil. From his official announcement HERE:

"The novel, Os Dias da Peste (In an approximate translation, In the Days of the Plague), is a post-cyber near-future story involving the birth of real AIs. This was a long time coming, and I wanted to share it with you.

The cover art is by Marcelo Tonidandel, who also painted the cover of the first Brazilian Steampunk anthology (there´s a short story of mine in there as well).

I´ll be signing the novel in a kind of micro-book tour (four events in different cities in Brazil this year, with more to come in early 2010). The first one will be later today (yep, Friday 13rd - I wouldn´t let this pass). Wish me luck!"


We hope the novel will be available in an English translation soon and in the meantime to get a flavor of Fabio's fiction do not forget to check out his online short stories indexed HERE or on the front page of our site.

Cindy, Liviu, Robert and Mihir congratulate Fabio on his major achievement and wish him luck!!

"Red Claw" by Philip Palmer (Reviewed by Liviu Suciu)



Order "Red Claw" HERE
Official Philip Palmer Website
Read FBC Review (R. Thompson) of "Debatable Spaces" HERE

Introduction:
Last year Philip Palmer published a very original and superb (imho) debut "Debatable Spaces". Unusual and daring for sff in structure and style, that novel pushed at the stylistic boundaries of the genre within a traditional space-opera framework. Robert Thompson reviewed Debatable Spaces for FBC and I wholeheartedly agree with his summation:

"In conclusion, Philip Palmer’sDebatable Space” is one heck of a trip. It’s ambitious, original, a self-contained story, laugh-out-loud funny, gleefully violent, and wildly unpredictable."

So I was very eager for Mr. Palmer's next novel and I read "Red Claw" on receiving it. A page turner and keeping my unabated attention to the end, I felt though that the author retreated from the cutting edge of the genre into more traditional and well worn sf territory so from that point of view I felt Red Claw somewhat of a step back, however technically more accomplished it was.

Overview/Analysis: A standalone "expedition, planet with monsters, rogue soldiers and mad scientists" novel set in the same universe as Debatable Spaces, "Red Claw" reminded me strongly of David Drake's Redliners, though Mr. Palmer's novel is quite strongly anti-militaristic as opposed to the unabashed military bent of veteran Drake's work.

Quite accomplished technically since it kept many of the literary flourishes of Debatable Spaces but it also managed to eliminate the narrative walls in which the earlier novel sometimes ran into - so the pages turn by themselves despite the frequent changes of style, pov's and narration pace - I thought that if you were a newbie to the "planet with monsters" sf-subgenre, this novel could blow you away. However for a veteran reader of such, the novel while very good does not bring anything new and this subgenre strongly depends on novelty since by its structure, characters are rarely more than sketches.

There were lots of great scenes, emotion and suspense, but I thought the total result somewhat less then the sum of its parts since "Red Claw" lacks a total integration of its main revenge/escape plot into the "planet with monsters" setup, so while we get some resolution at the end, there is also a strong "oh, we could have switched the monsters with a dangerous maze or something similar and nothing would have changed".

Since the novel keeps you absorbed end to end and the monsters are still cool despite their somewhat redundancy as far as the big picture goes, I am recommending it without qualms, but I wish Mr. Palmer will get back to the ambition and panache exhibited in Debatable Spaces and combine that with the narrative energy and technical execution from this one.


Overall if you loved Debatable Spaces or you want cool monsters, try this one since it will give you a rollicking and imaginative adventure!

Sunday, November 15, 2009

"Time Travelers Never Die" by Jack McDevitt (reviewed by Liviu Suciu)



Order “Time Travelers Never Die Here
Official Jack McDevitt Website
Read FBC Review of The Devil's Eye

Introduction: Ever since I read “A Talent for War” fifteen years or more ago, I have been a big-time Jack McDevitt fan, having bought and read all of his books on publication with the aforementioned “A Talent for War” and “Engines of God” being among my top science fiction novels of all time. Mr. McDevitt does not write “big idea” sf, but is a great storyteller and his books hook you and are impossible to put down.

Since time travel is among my least favorite sf tropes due to its inherently solipsistic nature, I hesitated getting this one despite the above comments about Mr. McDevitt - after all disaster novels are also among the least favorite sf type of mine and the only McDevitt book I disliked was of that kind; moreover in quite a few situations when an author on my buy on publication list started writing time travel stories, they fell flat for me - so I waited for a chance to browse the novel in stores before committing. However once I opened it, I could not put it down, *had to get it then* and I stayed very late in the night to finish it and then I re-read it the next day also to savor it at leisure.

Overview/Analysis: "Time Travelers Never Die" is a typical McDevitt book that keeps you engrossed while you do not want to question too much its premises; our bumbling but endearing heroes, Shel and Dave travel throughout history and have many (mis) adventures, mostly due to their ineptness; Shel's father, the inventor of the time travel device is missing, but several devices are in a safe in his house and when a letter surfaces telling Shel the gist of the situation and asking him to destroy the devices, Shel cannot resist and with best friend and classics professor Dave, they head on a romp through history in search of the elder physicist.

Of the many historical cameos, Aristarchus of Alexandria, the civil rights leaders of the 60's and some of the Founding Fathers are the best, with a Borgia and the goons in the 60's south suitably menacing...

The action in the past intertwines well with the one in the present; as usual there is a mysterious "grandparent principle" that somehow stops paradoxes from happening - if a time traveler tries to generate one, it tends to be fatal or close as both Shel's father and our two heroes discover. There is romance, discovery, fun and tragedy.

A great ending and the book hangs together though it's more "Time Traveler's Wife" with a missing father rather than romance, than "serious" sf; there is room for more and I would welcome another book in the same universe though it stands well on its own; I know there is an Alex Benedict next from Mr. McDevitt though since Hutch is retired maybe we see more Q-pods time travelers after that.

One of the best lighter sf novels of the year and highly recommended with the caveat above.

Friday, November 13, 2009

Travels through Balaia: An Interview with James Barclay


Visit James Barclays site here
Read Fantasy Book Critic's Review of Dawnthief here

I have been a fan of James Barclay's writing for at least 4 years since I discovered his Raven series in the library one day. I am extremely lucky to be able to sit down and interview James Barclay for Fantasy Book Critic.

James Barclay's Chronicles of Raven series was recently brought to the US this September by Pyr. In this interview Barclay explores who he'd most want to be in the Raven series, talks about his upcoming new series released in 2010, and even has exciting news regarding the Legend of Raven series.

Cindy Hannikman would like to thank Mihir Wanchoo for helping out with some of the questions. And a very special thanks goes out to James Barclay for participating and Jill from Pyr for helping arrange the interview.

*************************************************************************************

1. Why don't you tell us a little bit about yourself for those that are unfamiliar with James Barclay?

People are unfamiliar with me? Who? I want them caught and shot now. And now, returning to the real world, briefly at least... I’m an English fantasy author (I have to say ‘English’, partly because I feel parochial sometimes but mainly because there is a Scottish author who shares my name. He writes comedy stuff). I’m heading towards my mid-forties at breakneck speed; I’m married to Clare; we have a son, Oscar, who is three in January 2010; and we have a dog, Mollie. She is a Hungarian Vizsla for those who want to know. We all live very happily, if rather noisily, in a place called Teddington which is about half an hour south west of London.

I had a career in financial services marketing and advertising that began in 1987, which went hand in hand with my novel writing between 1998 and 2004 and it was in March 2004 that I managed to go full time as an author. That was a great day and I’ll forever be grateful that I get paid for doing the thing I love the best. Not many are so lucky.

I’m best known in the UK and Europe for my books about ageing mercenary team, The Raven. They are designed to be action packed thrill rides and pretty much achieve that, I think. Heroic Action Fantasy is their official title, I’m told. Plenty of humour in there too, and, I like to believe, characters that grow on you whether you like it or not. There are seven books in the series. Two linked trilogies and a seventh tale that fits terribly neatly at the end of it all. I’m proud of the fact that The Raven had their genesis in a dice-based RPG I played about twenty five years ago. The influences are there to see in Dawnthief but fade away quickly after that.

I’ve also written an epic duology entitled, ‘The Ascendants of Estorea’ which is based in a Roman-esque society and deals with the birth of magic in a land that has not seen its like before and manifests itself in four teenagers. Two novellas have sprung from this mind too. One, ‘Light Stealer’ deals with the invention of Dawnthief. The other, ‘Vault of Deeds’ is a comedy, don’t you know. Loved writing that. Just loved it.

Oh and before I forget and before anyone needs to be nudged back to consciousness, I’m an actor too. Stunningly unsuccessful from the moment I left drama school way back in 1987 (hence the office-based career) but just recently doing the odd bit of work. A small role as a detective in a gritty Brit-pic is going to be followed by a larger role as the same detective in the sequel. The first film is called ‘The Estate’ and it’s out in some form or other in 2010.

Being English, I’m a lover of many sports in which the English are not the best. Not at the moment, anyway. Cricket, football, rugby union. I play tennis too. Fairly badly. Love films but hardly ever get to the cinema. Love cooking too. Love playing shooters and strategy on the PC. But mostly I love watching my son grow. That is simply wonderful.

2. What started you writing? Did you have any influences that helped you get started?

I’ve just always done it. If I had influences to begin with it would be my whole family. I’ve two sisters and a brother. I’m the third in line, by the way. All of us love reading and so I was always around books and learned to read very young. I merely took it one stage further and began to write my own stories too. My first recorded work is about an Inuit kayaking along a glacial river. I wrote that when I was six and had a broken arm. I remember it because I couldn’t hold the paper down and every line veers downwards after a good horizontal start. Basically, I never stopped. It’s been fantasy stuff since I was about eleven.

3. Did your background in acting and theatre help you in writing?

There was time when I would have said ‘No’ to this but actually I think it did and does help. While my writing is certainly, and deliberately, not massively detailed, it is very visual. I literally do see my characters doing whatever it is they do and saying whatever it is they say. Perhaps every author does but I place them as if on a stage so I know where each one is in relation to the others. My dialogue has the feel of a script about it when I’m writing it and I’m always fully conscious of pace and where I think I might lose the audience. Like an actor, I don’t get it right every time but there are instincts you develop as an actor that I’ve brought to my writing for sure.

4. Some writers have detailed outlines and know what will happen when. Some writers just let their characters take the wheel and go where they go. Which writer are you?

There are times when I’d love to be the former but I am very much the latter. For me, being the latter means there are times in the writing process where I can feel quite at a loss which way to go next and that is never a good feeling. But I counter balance it by not being constrained by anything choreographed before I start to type. It’s meant that I’ve changed endings, beginnings, who lives and dies.. pretty much everything. This is nearly always beneficial as I’m not afraid to ditch something that isn’t working and also can see when a character is shouting for more attention.

My favourite example of this is in the first Ascendants book, ‘Cry of the Newborn’. I had a bit-part character in my head. Sort of chief tax-gatherer type. I was going to use him as a demonstration of the power of the empire. But from the first moment he rode into a village and began to speak, he was destined to be so much more. He just oozed interesting conflicts. Paul Jhered, Exchequer of the Conquord. Only an idiot has a taxman as a hero. I am that idiot.

5. The Raven series started out in the UK in 2002 (and probably in your head a while before that). It's been 7 years before it made it to the US. Why do you think there was such a delay in bringing it across the pond?

It had been in my head for absolutely ages. It even had a brief outing as a comedy novel. Short-lived, thankfully. Actually, Dawnthief first graced the shelves in July 1999 so it’s been a whole decade stuck this side of the Atlantic. I don’t really know why it took so long to make the transition. I guess like when you’re trying to sell your first novel, there is no guarantee, however good it is, that it will fall in front of the right person ever. UK fantasy may not have been all that popular in the US last millennium or something. Perhaps there was a flood and I was in the backwash. Who knows? All I do know is that it was utterly frustrating and that I have to give huge thanks to my US agent, Howard Morhaim who never gave up trying, and of course, Lou Anders at Pyr books who took The Raven on.

6. What do you think makes the Raven series appear so timeless that it can be accepted so many years later as if it were written just yesterday?

That’s a very good question and one I’m delighted to be asked. Plenty of chance for ego-buffing and all that. When I think about it seriously, it’s down to language and the treatment of some of the standard fantasy tropes, mainly. I deliberately chose modern language for dialogue as well as everything else. Mostly because I can’t write in olde worlde style and frankly, don’t want to. Unless you are really good, it comes out hackneyed and stilted. Not doing so had the benefit of keeping it fresh. I know swearing in fantasy books is terribly common now but even my few expletives raised some eyebrows at the time. In an earlier draft, there were many more. Even so, someone sent their copy of Dawnthief back because of the ‘crude and gutter language’ it used. God knows what they’d make of an Abercrombie or a Lynch...

I tried to put a new spin on fantasy staples too. Dragons have a raison d’être beyond burning things and sitting on piles of gold. As the series develops, you find that my version of elves casts them as a very different animal to any in book or film I’ve seen. But in the Chronicles, it is the heroes who get the main treatment. The Raven are not all-conquering and most certainly not immortal. They are very much individuals, they bicker, fight and moan. They don’t always pick the right option. Their plans do not necessarily pan out the way they want. Some of them even hatch children. And while they always want the right ultimate outcome, they’re morally grey. We have to remember that they begin as hired killers. These are not people who wear white hats. But it makes them real, if you like. They’re only human (or elven...). People related to that ten years ago and they still do.

7. So far are you pleased with the reaction of the Raven in the US?

Delighted. I mean, I may only have seen the good reviews so far but reviewers have been amazingly positive and that gives me a warm feeling, don’t you know. Naturally, sales can always be better but they’ve been most decent and that’s just fine by me. I hope that continues.

8. Every writer enjoys all the characters in their book. Who is your favourite? And who did you enjoy writing the most?

Oh, blimey, this is really hard. I could give you a long list but if I really, really had to choose one, then... after a run-off with Ilkar, it would have to be Hirad. This is because he is so simple on the surface but so terribly complex behind his loudmouthed bravado. He is the heartbeat of The Raven, the driving force of passion and belief that brings them through the tough tests. Hirad is incredibly brave, extremely skilled and occasionally foolhardy. He has a quick temper with friend and foe alike. Yet his capacity for love is enormous. And his loyalty to those he loves is bottomless. He is witty and plays on his lack of education and barbarian upbringing (barbarian in my books means uncivilised. I get criticised for calling him a barbarian because he doesn’t fit into the fantasy-standard definition. Me, I looked in the Oxford English dictionary and he fits that definition just fine). If you had to pick one man to stand with you in a desperate fight, it would be Hirad every time. Love him.

But who did I enjoy writing the most? Well that is different. Writing Raven characters across the seven books is occasionally very difficult and hugely emotional. And while I draw great satisfaction from getting them right, ‘enjoy’ isn’t always a term I’d always use to describe the process. Blubbing at your PC is not enjoyable, it just isn’t. Surprising, yes. So I’m going to choose a character from Elfsorrow which is the first book of the Legends trilogy and his name is Captain Yron. He’s one of those like Jhered (see above...) who began as bit part players and ended up as pivotal. He’s grizzled, cynical and difficult to please. He’s a career soldier, far more loyal to his men than his masters. He’s falling out of love with the machinations of Xetesk and reveals himself to be a man of integrity and heart, a man who refuses to take the easy way out. I loved writing his journey in the book. The sideshow of his tutelage of a young soldier in his command was an unexpected gift to me as I wrote. It was just a shame he didn’t have a place in any other volumes.

9. Are there any future plans for the Raven both in the US or the UK?

Well, I can announce here that a deal has been done with the magnificent Lou Anders and Pyr Books to publish the Legends of The Raven trilogy. I hope Ravensoul follows them on to the bookshelves of the US. As far as I’m concerned, after Ravensoul, there won’t be any more novels about The Raven themselves. But that needn’t be the end. Film and TV are mediums in which I think The Raven would thrive. I’m working on a screenplay of Dawnthief when I can as well as examining how I might adapt the novels for multi-episode TV. Options are still available, by the way J. I’m currently working with developers on a Raven rpg/strategy computer game and we’ll see if that bears fruit. Signs are positive but money is scarce... I’m a big gaming fan by the way so as far as I’m concerned, any Raven game will be brilliant or not made at all.

10. You have a new series starting in 2010. What can you tell us about this series? What can we the readers expect as far as writing style?

Well, it’s a new trilogy of books concerning the Elves of the Raven’s world. It covers their bloody and difficult history over about three thousand years up to the point where the spell, Dawnthief, is discovered, which itself is about three hundred years before the Raven are born. The Elves live on a continent far to the south of Balaia, called Calaius. It is dominated by rainforest and the elves are a complex lot, riven along lines of longevity that are linked to the gods they worship. They also do not ride horses. Nor do they use longbows.

The first book, ‘Once Walked With Gods’ deals with a breakdown of elven society, the unwelcome intervention of humans and the trials of a fallen hero. Subsequent novels deal with consequences, the ongoing conflict between elves and man, the development of characters and, like always with me, each book reaches a proper conclusion rather than setting up the next (which it will also do but not as its prime driving force). I know that’s vague but I’m not through the second book yet and given an earlier answer, you wouldn’t expect me to know too much detail, would you?

The writing style owes a great deal more to the Raven than the Ascendants of Estorea. The books will be back to pace-driven action fantasy with, I sincerely hope, characters people can love, hate, shout at in frustration and cry over, as well as dealing with themes that matter. I hope readers in the US are not waiting ten years for them. Going out and buying the Raven now will help reduce that wait J.

By the way, that isn’t the only new work I’m involved with. I’m writing a series of Young Adult novels too, first one scheduled for Spring 2011. More on that anon but I’m both very excited and a little nervous to be stepping outside the relative security of the fantasy genre and into mainstream fiction.

11. Let's put you in Balaia for these questions. Would you want to be a part of the Raven? Do you think they would even accept you in the exclusive group of theirs? If not, what role would you be playing in Balaia (mage, rogue warrior, even a bar owner in a small city!).

Well, I suppose I can dream of being in any way brave, strong and enduring enough to be part of them though I doubt very much they’d want me with them. Fighting has never been a strong point of mine. Nor violent confrontation of any kind. I write about it instead. Far safer. I think I’d be a mentor to mages. A skilled mage in my own right but rather than seek the highest positions of college power, I’d school those wanting a life as a mage in exactly what it means. Sounds a bit pappy, I suppose but it would leave me at the centre of things, respected, admired and with few enemies. These are things that benefit the desire for a long life...

12. This year was the debut for the David Gemmell Legend award, what are your thoughts on its inception? How involved were you with the award process & how do you foresee the future of the DGLA?

Dave Gemmell was a very good friend of mine, a mentor and pillar of strength. His death was desperately sad for me personally and a disaster for the genre because he was such a champion and was writing at his very best with the Troy series. I will always miss sitting in his house in the early hours talking about authorly things and feeling blessed that I met him one day on a train to Paris. That’s a tale for another day.

So for me, the DGLA was and is a fitting tribute to the undisputed king of heroic fantasy and a man who believed personally in the five key pillars of his work – love, friendship, honour, courage and redemption. I’ve been involved in the process from the very start but the real driving forces behind it have been Stan Nicholls and Debbie Miller (the author, Miller Lau). All of us have been touched by Dave’s generous spirit as a friend, tutor or mentor. Dave was best man at Stan’s wedding. Their friendship goes back decades. On the night, I had the honour of opening the event by dramatising a speech from Legend. It was the call to arms Druss gives the defenders of Dros Delnoch on the eve of battle against the Nadir. It was an emotional moment and well-received I think. Later I hosted the raffle which was just a blast.

The future for the Award is bright so long as we keep working and promoting it. We need to raise funds too and that is always a challenge. We’re going to expand the number of categories and do as much as possible to keep it front of mind as voting begins, right through to the awards night itself. The inaugural night far exceeded my expectations but I still think there are things we can do better. I’m excited about the future for the award. It deserves to be the premier fantasy award hosted here in the UK. Anyone who wants to know more about the DGLA, please get along to www.gemmellaward.ning.com for all you need to know. There’s even a link there to the audio from the 2009 event so if you want to hear my speech, you can.
13. You must be tremendously overjoyed with England reclaiming the Ashes this year. But from a purist's point of view, which series win was more thrilling/satisfying, the 2005 or the 2009?

Utterly overjoyed. Even more so given our dreadful thrashing in Australia last time around. It was a fine series, introducing plenty of new players to both sides. But the 2005 win was both more thrilling and satisfying. We hadn’t won for what seemed like ages and the Aussies were a hugely strong side. Ponting, Hayden, Clarke, Watson, Gilchrist, Langer, Warne and for a couple of tests, McGrath. We were strong too. Vaughan, Flintoff, Pietersen, Harmison, Hoggard, Jones and Giles. A proper heavyweight contest with no let up, not for one ball of a session. Brilliant stuff. Apologies to all those non-cricket fans for the list of names but for those who follow the sport, these were big names in a huge series. And beating the Aussies is everything to an English cricket fan.

14. What order do you recommend readers read the whole Raven series in? Can the Legend of Raven be read and understood without reading the Chronicles of Raven?

Well, and I would say this, read them from the beginning. The chronology is: Dawnthief, Noonshade, Nightchild. Elfsorrow, Shadowheart, Demonstorm, Ravensoul. Absolutely, yes the Legends can be read and understood without reading the Chronicles but why would you? Think how much action, emotion, character and sparkling dialogue you’ll be missing. You also get the free benefit of seeing how my writing improves from one novel to the next. What more could a fantasy fan want?

15. Anything else you'd like to include?

Well I think I’ve managed to discuss most of my life in one way or another. So much of it has revolved around The Raven, it seems, whether as an rpg in my teens or as writing novel upon novel about them. It’s been quite a journey. It’s a strange thing to live with characters for such a long time. They really do become an integral part of your life. I’ll look back on them with great fondness always. It was a double-edged moment when I finished Demonstorm. That was to be the last of them and I found myself utterly at a loss even though I had the Estorea novels to write immediately afterwards.

Being able to return to them with Ravensoul was an unlooked for pleasure and once I was done with that novel, I was able to walk away feeling somehow more complete. It seemed the tale was not told at the end of Demonstorm. It is now.

Oh, and finally, in that dice-based rpg? I was Hirad. Who else?

Thursday, November 12, 2009

Overlooked Title: "The Softwire: Virus on Orbis 1" by PJ Haarsma (Reviewed by Cindy Hannikman)


Visit the Softwire Website here
Order The Softwire: Virus on Orbis 1 here

Introduction: One of the many things that I have come across in my reading of many YA/Children's books is that there appears to be a slight gap in the science fiction literature written for that specific age group. While there might be the occasional space travel, or alien there isn't really a lot of books that are aimed at that age level that would really be science fiction. Many sci-fi books might read as a YA book but while they might be written in a style that could be YA are more for the adults then middle school or teen level of reading.

When I came across "The Softwire" series I was interested in seeing how the various concept were going to be presented in this book. As a reader of fantasy series, my experience with this series was overall surprising.

Overview: The children on board the ship Renaissance have only known what life was like traveling through space for the better part of 12 years. Their parents have all died in a freak accident that left them orphaned. In a strange twist of events the parents left the children in nourishing pods to be "born" only if something were to happen to them.

The adults of the Renaissance had made an agreement with the Council on Orbis, an advanced interplanetary plant that is known for the great life that is promises, that if the parents worked on the four rings of Orbis after four years they would be granted the chance to citizenship on Orbis and be able to lead a great life. However since the adults have all died when the children arrive at Orbis they are required to fulfill the agreement that their parents had promised. The children of the Renaissance must live a slave-life lifestyle, working one year on each of the rings of Orbis, if after that period of time their work is deemed acceptable they are allowed to become full fledged citizens of Orbis.

Orbis is an advanced technology state in that everything is run by a central computer system that controls everything from the food that is distributed to the security of the doors in all the buildings.

JT and his sister, Ketheria are two of the children on board the Renaissance and are forced to work sorting out junk parts for one of the higher citizens of Orbis. JT has always thought it was strange that he could communicate with the "mother" computer on board the Renaissance but as he had known no other life besides the one on board he thought this was normal. When he lands on Orbis he finds out he is a rare human known as a "Softwire", who is capable of linking up to any computer by just using his mind.

Coinciding with JT's arrival on Orbis, the central computer system has started going crazy. It started slowly with small problems such as doors not opening and computer mix ups, and slowly started progressing until it became so obvious it was impossible for the people of Orbis to ignore anymore. Many people believe that JT is the reason for all these problems because he is a Softwire, however while traveling through the computer system JT notices a virus has been planted into the central computer.

JT must try to convince the people of Orbis that he isn't the blame for the problems and that someone else is out to destroy Orbis. The virus has started many fights between the Keepers, the rulers of Orbis and the Trading Council, a group that wishes to rule Orbis. Both groups have an interest in JT, only which one wants him to help and which one wishes to see him dead is something JT must figure out.

Analysis: While PJ Haarsma's Softwire series began back in 2006, I hadn't heard much about it. As a matter of fact I was beginning to wonder if anyone would tempt to take on sci-fi for a younger audience besides the typical alien visitors to earth. What Haarsma created is not only unique but captivating at the same time.

Haarsma has created a unique world that is appealing to both adults and children. There are many various alien like creatures on the planet of Orbis, and there is also the humans that have arrived on the ship. The integration of the two species together is done very well and many of the characters that readers come into contact with appear to be pretty thought out. There are times when the characters do appear a bit rushed or hurried, but the main characters of JT and his sister are very three dimensional. The background of the characters and some of their trails and issues they encounter are life like and real.

The creation of the world of Orbis is another excellently done area of the book. The descriptions of the buildings and technology that is used are very detailed, and are easily able to be followed by any reader. There are no maps or pictures throughout the novel, but I could visualize everything that was described in my head. The technology that was involved in the book wasn't so complex that it got overwhelming or too confusing, sometimes when technology is involved readers almost feel like they need a degree in Information systems to understand what is going on. On the other hand, the technology isn't so watered down that it felt like the readers were being talked down to.

There are some gaps or downfalls with Virus on Orbis 1 that I encountered in my reading.

First was the reaction of the Citizens of Orbis to the virus threat. Whenever JT would bring up the subject of the virus, the aliens response was along the lines of "The computer runs all it'll tell us if there's a problem". I couldn't understand why that was the reaction. If the technology was so advanced that it would alert to a problem, shouldn't someone have known that there could be a problem? Maybe the citizens of Orbis just got too comfortable and were lulled into a false sense of security but it was a question that kept nagging me while I was reading the novel.

There were also other slight gaps in the story line, such as JT being placed in holding because he could be the problem and then magically he's let out and no one seems to be overly worried about him being the cause. While not a major problem with the book there were occasional gaps in the story that an older reader might notice but a younger reader wouldn't even think twice about it.

The second gap weakness of the book was what occurred at the ending. The events that happened within the last couple of pages just seemed to pop out of nowhere. There was not a bit of foreshadowing in the previous chapters and with what happened it almost seemed like there would have been some sign or knowledge of it before hand or at least some way to let the reader know it might be a possibility.

The last weakness that I encountered was that of the pacing of the book. Virus on Orbis 1 started out with a real bang and the novel just seemed to speed along, but once the virus was discovered the pacing seemed to drag a little. It wasn't until the last couple of pages that the pace really sped back up again.

In the end, some of the story lines gaps and unexplainable reactions might turn off a more experienced reader of sci-fi/fantasy. However The Softwire: Virus on Orbis 1 was a great novel to introduce readers to what could be out there in the sci-fi world, something that I hope other authors won't be as afraid to try. PJ Haarsma does a great job on what was his debut novel (He has since wrote 2 other books in the Softwire series) and it would be interesting to see where he takes the creativity in his other novels. The Softwire is definitely a series to check out if you are looking for a sci-fi adventure series that isn't too heavy or complicated.

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

"Midnight Guardian: A Millennial Novel" by Sarah Jane Stratford (Reviewed by Mihir Wanchoo)


Visit Sarah Jane Stratford's Website Here
Order Midnight Guardian Here

BOOK & AUTHOR INFORMATION:

Sarah Jane Stratford has a master's degree in medieval history from the University of York in England. She has previously written short stories and screenplays most notably "The Tale of the Torturer's Daughter".

Mightnight Guardian is Sarah Jane Stratford's debut novel. It is the first in the Millennial series. It was released on October 13, 2009 by St. Martin's press. The novel stands at 304 pages divided into 22 chapters. Midnight Guardian is told from the third person perspective of the two main protagonists Brigit and Eamon.

BOOK ANALYSIS & OVERVIEW:

As I was reading the book blurb about Midnight Guardian, in which main idea included Nazi Germany and features vampires as the main characters, my inner radar immediately went bonkers, and I knew I had to give this novel a try.

Midnight Guardian is set just before WWII (World War Two), with the first few chapters of the novel covering a wide time line. The prologue starts the novel out at the year of the Berlin Olympics, 1936. The first chapter of the novel then jumps to feature the vampires in the middle of Germany doing some of their many activities. The second time travels back nearly 2 years later, and features a tribunal of vampires set in Britain who are particularly worried about the events that are occurring in the continental Europe. The tribunal has had various reports from their vampire brethren about vampire hunting and a marching Nazi army that is starting to interfere with some of the tribunals plans and needs. The major problem that this tribunal faces is that the last time a major war broke out, World War I referred to as the "Great War" in this novel, the vampires faced famine-like conditions due to the massive amount of casualties. This famine led to an anarchy-like situation within the vampire domain, and the tribunal do not wish to see a repeat of this situation and hope to stop the war before it starts, and leads to major complications.

The story line begins with Brigit as she views Germany and the changes affected due to the Nazis. Brigit is one of a few group of vampires known as the millennials. The millennials are a bunch of vampires who have lived for more than 1000 years and thus have gained a lot of power in that time period. Five of these millennials are selected for a mission to eradicate the Nazi cause and make sure that the mistakes and events that lead up to the "Great War" are not repeated. Brigit often worries about the other members of her group, who are powerful but not as experienced as she is or trained for this particular endeavor. The only one of the 5 that seems to be trained and eager to carry out this mission is a vampire known as Mors. The other three of the group; Cleland, Swefred, and Meaghan are all powerful in their own right but appear to carry on with their own thoughts and actions.

Brigit and the millennials manage to infiltrate the working strata and try to work out the plans of the Nazi upper echelons. At the same time of this action, the story also focuses on Eamon, Brigit's vampire lover who happens to have been left behind due to the fact that he is not a member of the millennials. Eamon often frets about Brigit and her almost impossible task of stopping the Nazis.

As the novel progresses as far as time wise goes, readers are treated to a look at the past as the storyline also includes how Eamon and Brigit both got converted to vampires and the beginning of the love story that the novel seems to focus upon.

Meanwhile the story is also progressing as the millennials realize that their mission might not be as clandestine as they thought. These Nazis do not behave simply as the rest of mankind or what the millennials thought they would. There is also a twist in which Brigit and her group of millennials are forced to take their mission in a different direction.

Midnight Guardian disappointed me for a few couple of reasons.

First the meandering style of the narration was a slight distraction from the actual story line. The story starts out in the year of 1938 and then is moved into the year 1940 but then the the novel jumps back again to present a point and is fast forward back to the "present" day area of the novel. There are also moments of flashback into Brigit's page where readers see how she was converted, the meeting of her and Eamon, and many others. All this toing and froing makes reading and following the time line of events throughout the story a little confusing and makes the reading a bit complicated.

The second area of disappointment was in what I felt was a slight weirdness to the storyline. What I couldn't understand was that there were these five millennial vampires that were supposed to be some of the most powerful creatures of their kind, so why is it that they weren't able to deal with the Nazis in a much more thorough manner? There are explanations provided in the novel as to how the Germans have fortified themselves with Irish vampires hunters and other admirable hunters making them a bit of a stronger enemy then expected. However these millennials are supposed to be the supermen and women of the vampire race and yet they couldn't solve this Nazi problem. The conditions in the story just didn't seem to add up for myself and it a big loophole.

Although there were some disappointments there are some positives as well. Sarah Jane Stratford's prose is elegant in spite of the previous mentioned drawbacks. The dialogue and characterization is done fairly well. The highlight of this story is that of the romance between Eamon and Brigit, in which readers learn of the beginning of this love story and to the present romance, all of this is done very captivating.

Midnight Guardian is a case of me expecting something that wasn't presented to me. The novel is packaged as a historical thriller with vampires which is a bit misleading as the central focus of this novel really appears to be the relationship between Brigit and Eamon, their past and the present. My experience might have been better if this novel was presented more as a historical romance with some action instead of the other way around.

In the end, I was expecting something else completely and therefore I could not fully enjoy the book as much as I would have liked to. Since this is supposed to be a series, I would still readily read the second book of the series to see where Stratford takes this series and what she does with the ending of this book. I would also like to see how her writing progresses in her sophomore novel.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

The Ambergris Week - Part 2: Shriek: An Afterword


The weird dreams continued, and the man did the only thing he could under such circumstances, the only logical thing: he kept on writing them.

In his masterpiece Man Without Qualities, Robert Musil states that one should live life as if it were a novel and as if we were all were characters (in fact, the core of that idea is first proposed by Shakespeare in As You Like It, where the Bard writes that "all the world´s a stage/And all the men and women merely players".)

So is the case with the second installment of the weird oneirorabilia collected by Jeff VanderMeer in his dreamtravels, and put to words in 2006, four years after City of Saints and Madmen. Shriek: An Afterword is a testament of sorts written by art critic Janice Shriek to his brother, the disappeared historian Duncan Shriek: characters {?} living as real people living by Musil´s standards as if they were indeed characters in a novel.

This longest of afterwords, though, is already something twisted, since Janice herself seems to have vanished before its publication, and a returned Duncan copyedits the original text, not cutting anything, but adding his comment in brackets. So we have an inversion here, a kind of addendum to an afterword. (Or "famous last afterwords"?)

During a party attended by the famous Mary Sabon, Duncan´s former lover, Janice takes refuge at her room and starts writing what will become a kind of biography of her, his infamous brother, and ultimately of a dark period in the history of Ambergris, the Silence - when, in the course of one night, all 25,000 inhabitants of the city were killed by the gray caps, the mysterious dwellers of the underworld. Or were they? The Silence becomes one of the obsessions in the life of Duncan Shriek - obsessions that will transform him deeply, not only in soul, but also in body.

The stream of consciousness narrative technique, just slightly interrupted by Duncan´s brackets {but not very much}, takes the reader through an wild, bumpy ride - being at times also a {very} bad trip, turned more weird due to the wide spectrum of literary references the occasional seeker can find inside its pages: for instance, the terrible diatribe of the editor L. Gaudy to Duncan is slightly reminiscent of Harlan Ellison´s in I have no mouth and I must scream. The vision of the gargantuan machine in the underground bears comparison only to the contraption devised by Samuel Beckett in his novella The Lost Ones.

{Now, to compare authors is something of a cowardice - but you must also remember that some reviews beg a metalinguistical approach, in which the reviewer, though cannot in any given moment try to best the author whose work he/she is reviewing, becomes sort of infected by his/her style, language- such is the case here. That is the foremost (though not the only one) reason of the use of comparison in this review.}

Duncan´s addiction and his fate, even though we know {do we?} we´re not going to see it to its end, attracts us as moths to a flame - and we allow the story to do that to us, for we want to. We don´t want the fungal embraces that took over Duncan´s body in the gray caps´s sinister underworld, but we shiver in anticipation anyway - maybe just because we will never be touched by its spores; maybe a little saddened because this is not the case nor it will ever be. All we have to guide us is words, and they will have to suffice. {At least for now, that is.}

You will also notice that this week will extend into the other one -- it is only fitting, for the Calabrian Calendar used in Ambergris is by no standards akin to ours.


(This review was first posted in Post-Weird Thoughts)