Blog Listing
- @Number71
- Before We Go blog
- Best Fantasy Books HQ
- Book Reporter
- Bookworm Blues
- Charlotte's Library
- Civilian Reader
- CrimeReads
- Critical Mass
- Dark Wolf's Fantasy Reviews
- Everything is Nice
- FanFiAddict
- Fantasy & SciFi Lovin' News & Reviews
- Fantasy Cafe
- Fantasy Faction
- Fantasy Literature
- Gold Not Glittering
- GoodKindles
- Grimdark Magazine
- Hellnotes
- io9
- Jabberwock
- Jeff VanderMeer
- King of the Nerds
- Layers of Thought
- Lynn's Book Blog
- Neth Space
- Novel Notions
- Only The Best Science Fiction & Fantasy
- Pat's Fantasy Hotlist
- Pyr-O-Mania
- Reactor Mag
- Realms Of My Mind
- Rob's Blog O' Stuff
- Rockstarlit Bookasylum
- SciFiChick.com
- SFF Insiders
- Smorgasbord Fantasia
- Speculative Book Review
- Stainless Steel Droppings
- Tez Says
- The Antick Musings of G.B.H. Hornswoggler, Gent.
- The B&N Sci-Fi & Fantasy Blog
- The Bibliosanctum
- The Fantasy Hive
- The Fantasy Inn
- The Nocturnal Library
- The OF Blog
- The Qwillery
- The Reading Stray
- The Speculative Scotsman
- The Vinciolo Journal
- The Wertzone
- Thoughts Stained With Ink
- Val's Random Comments
- Voyager Books
- Walker of Worlds
- Whatever
- Whispers & Wonder
Blog Archive
-
▼
2026
(63)
-
▼
July
(13)
- Exclusive Cover Reveal: Children Of Sun And Moon (...
- Book review: Fabulous Bodies by Chuck Tingle
- Book review: The Tinder Box by M.R. Carey
- SPFBO XI Finalist review: Dogged by Michael R. Fle...
- Review: The Infinite State by Richard Swan
- Book review: The Mortedant's Peril by R.J. Barker
- COVER REVEAL: The Ashen Viper (The Forham Papers #...
- Review: The Eye of Leviathan by M.A. Carrick
- Review: Sunsplitter by S.A. MacLean
- EXCLUSIVE COVER REVEAL: To Dream a Darker Realm by...
- Book review: A Murder Most Fungal by Adrian M. Gibson
- Book review: Sister Svangerd and the Devil You Kno...
- SPFBO XI Finalists - our approach
-
▼
July
(13)
Reading wise 2015 was a bit difficult. While I read a lot of
books, there weren't a lot of books that I read that I truly enjoyed or loved.
The books I read were fair. They were solidly written, but I just didn't really
form an attachment to them that I like to form when reading books.
I read just over 175 books that included everything from
Japanese manga and children's picture books to 'oldie, but goodie' fantasy
novels and YA novels that spanned from contemporary to sci-fi/fantasy. The
following are some of my favorites from 2015. These include books that I
personally read in 2015 and does not reflect their publication date.
*****************************************************************
Book Scavenger by Jennifer Chambliss Bertman
I absolutely loved Book Scavenger. This fast-paced
children's adventure/mystery novel was a book lover's dream come true. A real
life treasure hunt is launched around the world for books that are hidden
throughout the cities. My only complaint about Book Scavenger was that it was
over far too soon, but I look forward to other books in the series. Easily one of my top 5 books for 2015.
Alister Grim's Odditorium by Gregory Funaro
Alister Grim's Odditorium had an odd steampunk/fantasy/Harry
Potter feel to it. It wasn't a Harry Potter knockoff by any stretch of the
imagination, but within the first few pages I really just 'clicked' with the
book.
One of the amazing things about this children's fantasy
novel is that Gregory Funaro really made everything come together. There were a
lot of creatures and plot themes thrown out there throughout the book. It could
be really easy for an author to lose their train of thought and appear lost,
but not with this book. Everything came together nicely and while it was a
busy/fast paced novel, it all worked out.
Rules of Ascension: Book One of the Forelands by David B.
Coe
It's an older, epic fantasy, but so good. Detailed plot,
lots of mystery, amazing characters. It does move a bit slowly at first as
readers get used to the world and magic and other elements, but before you know
it the book is over and you are yearning for the next one.
The Walls Around Us by Nova Ren Suma
This haunting YA novel takes readers into the extremely competitive
world of ballet. The novel follows Violet – an aspiring professional ballet
dancer – as she struggles to come to terms with exactly how she became so
successful. While learning about her success, readers are given a look into the
lives of the girls at Aurora Hills – a junior detention center – where not everyone
is what they seem to be. Violet's life crosses with the girls at Aurora Hills
in an odd and haunting way. Walls Around
Us is emotional, spooky, detailed and absolutely beautiful. As the mystery
slowly unfolded, it was amazing to see how everything was tied together.
The Six by Mark Alpert
I haven't had a chance to review this for Fantasy Book
Critic, but it was amazingly good. There aren't a lot of sci-fi novels out
there aimed at the YA audience. The Six is both sci-fi and evil computers
taking over the world. Highly recommended.
Serafina and the Black Cloak by Robert Beatty
I wasn't sure about Serafina and the Black Cloak, but when
all was said and done, it was a unique children's fantasy book. The setting was
different, which gave it a refreshing vibe. The characters eventually grew on
you. A good, solid read for anyone looking for something a little different,
but not wanting to stray too far from the norm.
The Fixer: Fixer 1 by Jennifer Lynn Barnes
Absolutely loved The Fixer. It was filled with detailed
characters, a mysterious plot that wasn't overly predictable, and beautiful
writing.
Lois Lane: Fallout by Gwenda Bond
Not every book that is Top Novel of 2015 material has to be
overly deep or completely unique. Fallout fits that category. The mystery in
this novel was written in a way that made it not seem so predictable and the
book was good – especially if you are looking for something that is a fun,
simple read. Of course, it helps that there is Lois Lane in it!
Castle Hangnail by Ursula Vernon
I love almost anything written by Ursula Vernon. Castle
Hangnail is no exception. It had funny/silly moments, a main character that you
can't help but love, and lots of witty, age-appropriate situations and
problems. It is one of those children's books that I think will appeal to both
adults and children alike.
Paperweight by Meg Haston
Paperweight isn't a fantasy/sci-fi novel, it is a
contemporary YA novel, but it is my emotional/deep read for the year. And it
was so, so good. Paperweight takes readers into a day in the life of a teen who
is struggling to overcome an eating disorder. It starts on the first day of her
rehab and follows her through her ups and downs, as she comes to term with what
she is doing, why she is doing it, and how she needs to go about healing.
Paperweight is not for those looking for light fluffy reads, but it is
amazingly good.
Peak: A Novel by Roland Smith
Another non-fantasy YA novel, but another amazing read. If
you ever wanted to experience what it was like to climb to the top of the
world's tallest mountain, Peak will take you there. I really felt as if I was
climbing the mountain right with the characters and going through their
struggles.
Honorable Mentions for 2015
- Jinx – Sage Blackwood
- Princess Ugg: Vol 1 – Ted Naifer
- Curse of the Iris: Jupiter Pirates 2 – Jason Fry
- Escape from Mr. Lemoncello's Library – Chris Grabenstein
- Uprooted – Naomi Novik
- Rump: The True Story of Rumpelstiltskin – Liesl Shurtliff
Order The Murdstone Trilogy HERE
AUTHOR INFORMATION: Mal Peet published his first novel, Keeper, in 2003. It was translated into several languages and won the Branford Boase Award. He next won the Carnegie Medal in 2005 and the Guardian Children’s Fiction Prize in 2009, as well as a Boston Globe–Horn Book Honor in 2012 for Life: An Exploded Diagram. Born in Norfolk, England, in 1947, Mal Peet passed away in 2015.
OVERVIEW: Award-winning YA author Philip Murdstone is in trouble. His star has waned. The world is leaving him behind. His agent, the ruthless Minerva Cinch, convinces him that his only hope is to write a sword-and-sorcery blockbuster. Unfortunately, Philip—allergic to the faintest trace of Tolkien—is utterly unsuited to the task. In a dark hour, a dwarfish stranger comes to his rescue. But the deal he makes with Pocket Wellfair turns out to have Faustian consequences. The Murdstone Trilogy is a richly dark comedy described by one U.K. reviewer as "totally insane in the best way possible."
FORMAT: The Murdstone Trilogy is a dark comedy and the first book for adults written by YA author Mal Peet. The story is told in three parts, one for every installment in the titular trilogy. It was published in the US by Candlewick on September 22, 2015 and is available in Hardcover and as an E-book and audiobook.
ANALYSIS: Reminiscent of Terry Pratchett in the best of ways, The Mursdtone Trilogy is sometimes silly, sometimes hysterical, and at all times ridiculously fun. Though comic fantasies that poke fun at genre tropes that have worn themselves into clichés are far from unique, Peet’s novel is entirely fresh and far more than a simple satire of fantasy. It’s also a brutal yet empathetic caricature of the life of a writer and a sarcastic look at the sometimes ludicrous fanfare accorded to fantasy novels.
I was immediately hooked by Peet’s beautiful narrative voice. Each sentence is packed full of detail, with every word carefully chosen so that they fit together perfectly. I often found myself rereading sentences out loud so I could hear their rhythmic sound and feel them roll off my tongue. From start to finish, the language masterfully captures the droll nature of the story.
Peet’s characters are all wonderfully detailed and appropriately exaggerated to fit the satirical tone of the novel. Personal favorites include Minerva Cinch, the self-serving agent who will do anything to maintain her hard-earned reputation and publish the next big hit; the crazy old twins referred as the Wyrd Sisters that run the public library in the small town of Flemworthy and finish each other’s sentences; Pocket Wellfair, a foul-mouthed dwarf straight out of a fantasy novel (literally); and Philip Murdstone himself, an author of literary YA fiction that has never read a fantasy novel before and yet is commissioned to write one because that’s what sells.
The story told is a dark comedy that feels very British in nature, like a fantasy version of Hot Fuzz. In it, author Philip Murdstone is asked to write a very particular type of fantasy novel, one in which there is a magical world referred to as a realm, elves that live in trees, dwarves that live underground, a dark lord who is oppressing everyone, and other classic aspects of an epic fantasy series. And then, in a drunken stupor, he is approached by Pocket Wellfair, a dwarf from just such a world who recounts its history and thus provides him with just such a story. Readers are left to decide for themselves whether or not the dwarf, the realm, and the rest are products of Murdstone’s intoxication or not. Regardless, as the story progresses, Murdstone becomes more and more involved in the happenings of the Realm, much like a writer whose own life is consumed by his or her books.
CONCLUSION: The Murdstone Trilogy is an absolute pleasure to read. I would highly recommend it for anyone with a sense of humor, especially aspiring or published authors of epic fantasy.
AUTHOR INFORMATION: Mal Peet published his first novel, Keeper, in 2003. It was translated into several languages and won the Branford Boase Award. He next won the Carnegie Medal in 2005 and the Guardian Children’s Fiction Prize in 2009, as well as a Boston Globe–Horn Book Honor in 2012 for Life: An Exploded Diagram. Born in Norfolk, England, in 1947, Mal Peet passed away in 2015.
OVERVIEW: Award-winning YA author Philip Murdstone is in trouble. His star has waned. The world is leaving him behind. His agent, the ruthless Minerva Cinch, convinces him that his only hope is to write a sword-and-sorcery blockbuster. Unfortunately, Philip—allergic to the faintest trace of Tolkien—is utterly unsuited to the task. In a dark hour, a dwarfish stranger comes to his rescue. But the deal he makes with Pocket Wellfair turns out to have Faustian consequences. The Murdstone Trilogy is a richly dark comedy described by one U.K. reviewer as "totally insane in the best way possible."
FORMAT: The Murdstone Trilogy is a dark comedy and the first book for adults written by YA author Mal Peet. The story is told in three parts, one for every installment in the titular trilogy. It was published in the US by Candlewick on September 22, 2015 and is available in Hardcover and as an E-book and audiobook.
ANALYSIS: Reminiscent of Terry Pratchett in the best of ways, The Mursdtone Trilogy is sometimes silly, sometimes hysterical, and at all times ridiculously fun. Though comic fantasies that poke fun at genre tropes that have worn themselves into clichés are far from unique, Peet’s novel is entirely fresh and far more than a simple satire of fantasy. It’s also a brutal yet empathetic caricature of the life of a writer and a sarcastic look at the sometimes ludicrous fanfare accorded to fantasy novels.
I was immediately hooked by Peet’s beautiful narrative voice. Each sentence is packed full of detail, with every word carefully chosen so that they fit together perfectly. I often found myself rereading sentences out loud so I could hear their rhythmic sound and feel them roll off my tongue. From start to finish, the language masterfully captures the droll nature of the story.
Peet’s characters are all wonderfully detailed and appropriately exaggerated to fit the satirical tone of the novel. Personal favorites include Minerva Cinch, the self-serving agent who will do anything to maintain her hard-earned reputation and publish the next big hit; the crazy old twins referred as the Wyrd Sisters that run the public library in the small town of Flemworthy and finish each other’s sentences; Pocket Wellfair, a foul-mouthed dwarf straight out of a fantasy novel (literally); and Philip Murdstone himself, an author of literary YA fiction that has never read a fantasy novel before and yet is commissioned to write one because that’s what sells.
The story told is a dark comedy that feels very British in nature, like a fantasy version of Hot Fuzz. In it, author Philip Murdstone is asked to write a very particular type of fantasy novel, one in which there is a magical world referred to as a realm, elves that live in trees, dwarves that live underground, a dark lord who is oppressing everyone, and other classic aspects of an epic fantasy series. And then, in a drunken stupor, he is approached by Pocket Wellfair, a dwarf from just such a world who recounts its history and thus provides him with just such a story. Readers are left to decide for themselves whether or not the dwarf, the realm, and the rest are products of Murdstone’s intoxication or not. Regardless, as the story progresses, Murdstone becomes more and more involved in the happenings of the Realm, much like a writer whose own life is consumed by his or her books.
CONCLUSION: The Murdstone Trilogy is an absolute pleasure to read. I would highly recommend it for anyone with a sense of humor, especially aspiring or published authors of epic fantasy.
I know, I know I'm quite late with posting this list . The last year was a big one for me. We had our firstborn, brought our first house and my book reading kind of went downhill because of lack of time. I wasn’t able to review many of the titles I read but I did enjoy them a lot. I wasn’t sure I was going to do this list but changed my mind due to an email from an Indian reader. So thank you Pradeep B. for your kind email and for spurring my lazy ass.
As has been the case with previous lists, a few of the linked reviews are from this site. I have linked most of the others from trusted sites, because I could not review them over here for the aforementioned reasons. The main reasoning for choosing these titles is the varied milieu of the plots, excellence in prose, characterization and the overall enjoyment they provided. And so without further ado, here are my choices...
TOP TEN NOVELS OF 2015:
1) Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel – This is a gorgeously written story about a post-apocalyptic world and a group of actors who struggle to retain art and Shakespeare. Featuring a varied cast, and some brilliant plotting, this 2014 book has me stumped with its ingenuity & the author's exquisite prose. Give it a shot if you love beautifully written stories and are passionate about literary arts.
2) One Good Dragon Deserves Another by Rachel Aaron – I must confess I'm a BIG fan of Rachel Aaron's work & after writing more than ten books; she has yet to disappoint me. OGDDA is the second volume of her genre-confounding Heartstrikers series and while OGDDA reads like a thriller, it’s an urban fantasy, SF mashup in its plot and is a fantastic read overall. If you haven't read any of her works, start with the Heartstrikers series as you are definitely in for a fun time.
3) The Liar’s Key by Mark Lawrence – When it comes to devious dark epic fantasy, perhaps there is none better than Mark Lawrence. With The Liar’s Key, we are reacquainted with Jalan & Snorri as they further stumble upon various ungodly magical machinations. The Liar’s Key is one of those rare sequels that completely outshines its predecessor and all previous books by Mark. It’s so good that I’m genuinely worried as to how The Wheel of Osheim might overcome it.
4) A Song Of Shadows by John Connolly – John Connolly is a maverick, and with his most recent book A Song Of Shadows, he successfully reinvigorates his series and gives further clues about the nature of the honeycomb world within his books. Focusing on a wounded Parker, we get a great look at his daughter as a possible main character in the offing. Plus there are more revelations about the things hunting Parker. A must read title if you are a fan of the Charlie Parker series.
5) The Labyrinth Of Flame by Courtney Schafer – This is the concluding volume of the Shattered Sigils trilogy & a book that was hugely awaited. I just got done with it a few days ago and as Ria mentions in this review, this book is just SPECTACULAR. Kudos to Courtney Schafer for writing such a fantastic ending. Make sure that this is one book that you do read if you don't plan to read anything else.
6) Six Of Crows by Leigh Bardugo – Six Of Crows is a tricky book, at first it appears to be catering to the YA audiences however those readers unbiased enough to give this book a shot will love its combination of a heist storyline mixed with memorable grey characters. Leigh Bardugo showcases tremendous flair and gumption with this fast-paced book set in the world of the Grisha and doesn’t hesitate to showcase the dark side of her characters.
7) Twelve Kings In Sharakhai by Bradley P. Beaulieu – Brad Beaulieu is known to build intriguing and exquisite worlds & magic systems. With his debut trilogy he gave a quasi-Russian culture and with this book he further ups his world-building ante. Set within a city in the deserts and with twelve immortals presiding over it. Twelve Kings in Sharakhai was a mesmerizing story that left me spellbound and made its sequel a must-read in 2016.
8) Chapelwood by Cherie Priest – This is the concluding volume of the Borden Dispatches & according to Cherie completes the Lovecraftian celestial angle. We are reacquainted with an older Lizzie who now comes to Alabama to deal with a true-life crime that has some other-worldly origins. A fascinating story that melds horror & a crime procedural feel, Chapelwood is Cherie Priest at her imaginative best.
9) Those Above by Daniel Polansky – Those Above is a dark little gem of a story and is Daniel Polansky’s polemic on Elves and their position in fantasy literature. This story has a grand storyline that focusses on four different human characters and the alien-like immortal elvish overlords that rule the world. Simmering with violence and dark acts, Those Above sets the stage magnificently for Those Below and a reckoning that is sure to change the fate of this world.
10) Hounacier by Seth Skorkowsky –Seth Skorkowsky's Hounacier is a lovely sort of quasi-sequel that while set in the same world as its predecessor Dämoren, focusses on a new protagonist and immortal weapon. Set in the city of New Orleans, the author brilliantly gives us a tale dripping in horror and mystery, which while much different from Dämoren, is no less weak. I thoroughly enjoyed this new direction taken by the author and can’t wait for the third volume Ibenus
10) Disciple Of The Wind by Steve Bein – Disciple Of The Wind is the ending volume of the Mariko trilogy as described by the author and as far as endings go, has more literal bang to it than any Michael Bay movie. Mixing urban fantasy with magical swords but by taking a GRRM-esque route with it. Steve Bein finishes the trilogy while leaving the readers desperately wanting more stories set within his world.
Honorable mentions to the following titles that narrowly missed out on this list:
- Winter’s Reach and The Instruments Of Control by Craig Schafer
TOP TEN DEBUT NOVELS:
1) The Girl With The Ghost Eyes by M. H. Boroson – The Girl With The Ghost Eyes is a debut that almost slipped me by. Set in the cusp of the twentieth century San Francisco, and mixing Chinese mythology, Asian monster mythos and a very engaging protagonist, this debut just wowed me through and through. I can’t mention enough how enthralling this story is and once you are finished with the book, like me you will want to read this author post to read a sequel short story.
2) The Traitor Baru Cormorant by Seth Dickinson – Seth Dickinson’s debut was a magnificent one for a couple of reasons; firstly the characterization that was top-notch and the protagonist held the reader’s attention throughout. Secondly this is a dark story and not just grimdark level but something that makes most dark fantasy seem light hearted fare. I’ve very high hopes for the sequel based on the promise shown here.
3) Last Song Before Night by Ilana C. Myers – This was a surprise for me, Ilana Myers produced a stunning magic system that is intricate and reminds me slightly of Dan Abraham’s debut series. Mixing epic fantasy with striking characterization and a fascinating magic system. Last Song Before Night is easily a debut that heralds the arrival of Ilana Myers as a major talent to watch out for.
4) The Library At Mount Char by Scott Hawkins – This was another doozy of a debut, Scott Hawkins basically wrote a version of Hogwarts and the Harry Potter world as imagined by Cormac McCarthy of Road fame. It’s a solid gut punch of a story about a group of quasi-immortals who have been brought together by a scary “Father” figure who does his best to harden them for a task. What the task is and what is actually happening in the story is for you to find out but safe to Scott Hawkins marked himself out.
5) Beyond Redemption by Michael Fletcher – This debut has to be possibly the debut with regards to the conceptualization of a magic system. Focusing on a world wherein magic arises from delusions, and other mind disorders, Michael Fletcher gives us a story about individuals who are borderline insane, very dangerous and wholly intriguing. Kudis to the author for coming up with such an original magic system and dark storyline.
6) The Thief Who Pulled On Trouble’s Braids by Michael McClung – This was a debut which I came across via the Self Published Fantasy Blog Off. Combining Sword and sorcery elements but with a dark flair akin to Scott Lynch’s Gentleman Bastard books, Michael McClung gives us Amra Thetys and the world she inhabits. A debut about a thief with morals and an impending apocalypse, I can’t recommend this debut enough and will be very excited to read the sequels forthcoming.
7) An Ember In The Ashes by Sabaa Tahir – A YA book that managed to outgrow it’s genre trappings and focused on compelling characters. Sabaa Tahir’s story of young characters caught in a maelstrom of freedom struggle, betrayal, revolution and kindness was a fun read and I look forward to the sequel to see where she takes the story.
8) The Rules Of Supervillainy by C.T. Phipps – This was a superb debut that focuses on the authors love for comics and catch-22 situations most comic book villains find themselves in. Written as an ode to comic book stories in the 80s & 90s, C. T. Phipps manages to brilliantly combine compelling characters and superpowers to give us a story that will have you heartily cheering for a super villain who’s figuring out that he might not be one after all.
9) Grace Of Kings by Ken Liu – Grace Of Kings was a solid epic fantasy entry based on Chinese medieval history and mythology. Ken Liu’s prose was lofty and the way he structured the story, it was hard not to get drawn into the fascinating struggles between human, immortals and the kingdoms they inhabit.
10) Sorcerer To The Crown by Zen Cho – This debut imagines magic within a Victorian England and the effects of magic present within the world. Mixing Southeast Asian mythos with compelling characters (read Prunella), Zen Cho gives us a debut that will have you rooting for the plucky characters and think of this as a better-written and more accessible version Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell.
Monday, January 18, 2016
"The Scorpion Rules: Prisoners of Peace 1" by Erin Bow (Reviewed by Cindy Hannikman)
Visit Erin Bow's Official Website Here
OVERVIEW: The
world is at peace, said the
Utterances. And really, if the odd
princess has a hard day, is that too much to ask?
Greta is a duchess and crown princess—and a hostage to peace. This is how the game is played: if you want to rule, you must give one of your children as a hostage. Go to war and your hostage dies.
Greta will be free if she can survive until her eighteenth birthday. Until then she lives in the Precepture school with the daughters and sons of the world’s leaders. Like them, she is taught to obey the machines that control their lives. Like them, she is prepared to die with dignity, if she must. But everything changes when a new hostage arrives. Elián is a boy who refuses to play by the rules, a boy who defies everything Greta has ever been taught. And he opens Greta’s eyes to the brutality of the system they live under—and to her own power.
As Greta and Elián watch their nations tip closer to war, Greta becomes a target in a new kind of game. A game that will end up killing them both—unless she can find a way to break all the rules.
Greta is a duchess and crown princess—and a hostage to peace. This is how the game is played: if you want to rule, you must give one of your children as a hostage. Go to war and your hostage dies.
Greta will be free if she can survive until her eighteenth birthday. Until then she lives in the Precepture school with the daughters and sons of the world’s leaders. Like them, she is taught to obey the machines that control their lives. Like them, she is prepared to die with dignity, if she must. But everything changes when a new hostage arrives. Elián is a boy who refuses to play by the rules, a boy who defies everything Greta has ever been taught. And he opens Greta’s eyes to the brutality of the system they live under—and to her own power.
As Greta and Elián watch their nations tip closer to war, Greta becomes a target in a new kind of game. A game that will end up killing them both—unless she can find a way to break all the rules.
FORMAT: The
Scorpion Rules is the first in a series of YA sci-fi dystopian novels.
It stands at 384 pages and was published September 22, 2015 by Margaret K.
McElderry Books.
ANALYSIS: When I read the summary for The Scorpion Rules, I was
extremely excited about the book. It had a Hunger Games vibe, but it sounded
like it had a concept and a plot that was unique enough to separate it from all
the traditional run-of-the-mill YA dystopian novels out there. I was actually
relieved to see an author take a chance and stray from the norm. Unfortunately,
what was presented and what readers got were two totally different things.
Before I can even begin to review this novel, I have to
mention this book has goats - lots and lots and lots of goats. The goats are
supposed to be used for what I can only assume is comedic relief, as there are
some scenes with the goats running wild or doing silly things to the
characters. Things would have been okay if that was how it was used –
sparingly. Sadly, it wasn't.
There are lots and lots of details about the goats. The
goats mating habits, their importance to the world, the way the characters take
care of the goats. In fact, the first half of the book is spent so much time on
the goats. With so much focus on the goats, you would assume they would serve
some sort of purpose to the story or turn out to be some superhero that saves
the world, but they didn't. They were just goats being goats. And readers got
to learn a lot about goats.
It almost felt like the author was given a challenge of
'create a dystopian novel like Hunger Games, but make sure to use goats as a
major part of the plot'.
Why am I so focused on the goats? It is because while so
much time and energy is spent bringing up the goats, the characters of the book
are overlooked. There wasn't a whole lot of character building or getting to
know the characters for who they are. If a little less time had been spent on
the goats and more time spent on the characters, this might have been a
different book and I would have felt differently, but it wasn't.
Greta, our main character, came across as extremely flat.
She appeared to be wishy-washy in how she thought and I couldn't for the life
of me figure out what made her so special. It felt almost like one character
was just picked to be the star and she happened to be in the right place at the
right time. I just felt nothing for her and didn't understand why everyone
turned to her for advice and guidance.
If you can get past the goats, the book does eventually
start to pick up in terms of plot. Unfortunately, this was a case of 'too
little, too late'. It wasn't until the book was more than halfway over that
things started to pick up – right around the time when Talis (the big, bad guy)
comes onto the scene.
Talis was really the only character that really stood out to
me. This could be why the book seemed to pick up once he came on the scene. He
was charismatic, fleshed-out in terms of development, and was just really,
really good at being bad. In fact, without him I don't think I would have
enjoyed the book at all. Talis made the book.
There is one other thing to mention, the romance/bisexual love
triangle. Scorpion Rules has the ultimate insta-love. Greta sees Elian
from a distance and she instantly bonds with him. He is the one, he is her
obsession. That is until all of a sudden her roommate – Xie – starts hitting on
her. Then she decides that Xie is her one true love and instantly puts Elian in
the 'friends only' zone.
This is probably a result of the poor character development,
but I just felt nothing for this angle of the book. In fact, it came off as
trying too hard to fit in some sort of love triangle, but this time with a
diverse bisexual twist. It just didn't seem to work. Add the fact that it felt
like it happened instantly – one moment Greta is all up in arms and in love
with Elian, the next she's insta-bonded to Xie - and it just didn't seem to work.
Erin Bow is an
amazing author. I've read other books by her and they were good, but Scorpion
Rules just didn't do it. The sluggish pacing, poor character
development, and overuse of goats, turned what could have been a good book into
a rather boring, so-so novel.
The book does pick up towards the end and there is a glimmer
of hope that maybe the series can turn around. Unfortunately, I am not sure
enough readers will stick it out to get to the point where the book starts to
get good and of course then it quickly ends because there is another book on
the horizon.
Thursday, January 14, 2016
Sequel Series Cover Reveal & Mini-Interview with Rob J. Hayes (by Mihir Wanchoo)
Long time readers of the blog know how much I love indie authors. One such indie author is Rob J. Hayes whom I discovered back in 2013. Rob released his books in quick succession and won me over with his brand of dark fantasy. He was then picked up by upcoming small press Ragnarok Publications who re-released his debut trilogy in 2014-15 with snazzy covers and re-edited books.
Recently Rob signed on with Ragnraok to release a sequel duology and a collection of short stories. Joe Martin owner of Ragnarok Publications was super kind to allow us to do a cover reveal for both books and Rob also answered a few questions about the upcoming books and the fantastic covers that they share.
Read ahead to feast your eyes on these fabulous covers and find out what lies ahead for the denizens of First Earth.
Q] Congratulations on these fantastic covers Rob and for the new series contracts. Please tell us as to how all of this came to pass?
RJB: Thanks and thank you for having me back again.
Well The Ties that Bind (TTtB) was never intended as a stand alone trilogy in the world of First Earth. It's actually a part of a much larger story that I want to tell. I mentioned this to Joe Martin and he bit my hand off at the elbow. So no sooner had I finished the first in my It Takes a Thief... series, I started work on Best Laid Plans, the follow up to The Ties that Bind and the next part in the story of First Earth.
Q] If I remember correctly, The Bound Folio was first announced, followed by Best Laid Plans. Please tell us a bit more about both these projects.
RJB: It was indeed. Actually The Bound Folio was first announced early in 2015, but it's taken a while for us to pull it all together.
The Bound Folio is a collection of eight short stories set in First Earth and expanding both on the world and giving a bit of back story to some of the characters. Two of them were actually written before The Ties that Bind and have been sitting gathering dust since then. It feels good to finally give them a home.
Best Laid Plans is the follow up to The Ties that Bind. It's a duology (which I'm still not entirely certain is a real word), and is set roughly 1 year after the events of TTtB and works as a stand alone story, but it's also intended to fit into the much larger story I'm telling in First Earth.
Recently Rob signed on with Ragnraok to release a sequel duology and a collection of short stories. Joe Martin owner of Ragnarok Publications was super kind to allow us to do a cover reveal for both books and Rob also answered a few questions about the upcoming books and the fantastic covers that they share.
Read ahead to feast your eyes on these fabulous covers and find out what lies ahead for the denizens of First Earth.
Q] Congratulations on these fantastic covers Rob and for the new series contracts. Please tell us as to how all of this came to pass?
RJB: Thanks and thank you for having me back again.
Well The Ties that Bind (TTtB) was never intended as a stand alone trilogy in the world of First Earth. It's actually a part of a much larger story that I want to tell. I mentioned this to Joe Martin and he bit my hand off at the elbow. So no sooner had I finished the first in my It Takes a Thief... series, I started work on Best Laid Plans, the follow up to The Ties that Bind and the next part in the story of First Earth.
Q] If I remember correctly, The Bound Folio was first announced, followed by Best Laid Plans. Please tell us a bit more about both these projects.
RJB: It was indeed. Actually The Bound Folio was first announced early in 2015, but it's taken a while for us to pull it all together.
The Bound Folio is a collection of eight short stories set in First Earth and expanding both on the world and giving a bit of back story to some of the characters. Two of them were actually written before The Ties that Bind and have been sitting gathering dust since then. It feels good to finally give them a home.
Best Laid Plans is the follow up to The Ties that Bind. It's a duology (which I'm still not entirely certain is a real word), and is set roughly 1 year after the events of TTtB and works as a stand alone story, but it's also intended to fit into the much larger story I'm telling in First Earth.
Q] The Bound Folio is a collection of stories that run the gamut of heroes, villains, psychopaths and everything else in between. Who are some of the characters that are featured in it and what made you write about them?
RJB: Wow. That's actually a big question. Each story focuses on a single point of view, but also has a supporting cast, some of whom folk might recognise from TTtB. I'll try to keep it succinct and just mention a few.
We'll start with Derran Fowl, the Sword of the North. He's a living legend in the current era of First Earth and is thought of as pretty much unbeatable. He's a Blademaster, the same order of warriors as Jezzet Vel'urn, and she referred to him as the shade of death... so he's pretty damned good in a fight. I wanted to give a bit of a back story to the Sword of the North because he's actually where the whole world started for me. He was the first character I created and fitted into the world. He also makes a brief appearance (for the first time) in Best Laid Plans, so I decided to give him his own little story.
The Kid is about a certain character who appears in The Heresy Within (THW). After I released the book a lot (and I mean A LOT) of people stated this character as the most unlikeable bastard I had created, which is no small feat considering the cast of THW. So I decided to write a short story featuring this character, giving them a bit of a back story and also humanising them a bit more. I like to try to make people hate my likeable characters and like my hateable characters.
Beck is a story about Arbiter Beck who was mentioned in The Price of Faith, but only briefly during one of Thanquil's memories. She has a starring role in Best Laid Plans and I wanted to give her a swashbuckling pirate adventure before that role begins so the short story brings her right up to where Where Loyalties Lie starts.
Q] The Best Laid Plans duology features a storyline and characters who weren’t quite major players in previous trilogy except one pirate who seems to be everywhere. What was your reasoning for this change in characters and world location?
RJB: Well I love pirates almost as much as I love witch hunters so I figured I should write a book about them.
The wheel keeps turning and there's more to the world than the wilds. I wanted to give a view of a different, but equally as dangerous and gritty, part of the world and the events that transpire in Best Laid Plans will fit into the larger story I'm telling. Some of the major players from TTtB will return, although in bit parts, but for the most part it's a fresh new cast.
RJB: Wow. That's actually a big question. Each story focuses on a single point of view, but also has a supporting cast, some of whom folk might recognise from TTtB. I'll try to keep it succinct and just mention a few.
We'll start with Derran Fowl, the Sword of the North. He's a living legend in the current era of First Earth and is thought of as pretty much unbeatable. He's a Blademaster, the same order of warriors as Jezzet Vel'urn, and she referred to him as the shade of death... so he's pretty damned good in a fight. I wanted to give a bit of a back story to the Sword of the North because he's actually where the whole world started for me. He was the first character I created and fitted into the world. He also makes a brief appearance (for the first time) in Best Laid Plans, so I decided to give him his own little story.
The Kid is about a certain character who appears in The Heresy Within (THW). After I released the book a lot (and I mean A LOT) of people stated this character as the most unlikeable bastard I had created, which is no small feat considering the cast of THW. So I decided to write a short story featuring this character, giving them a bit of a back story and also humanising them a bit more. I like to try to make people hate my likeable characters and like my hateable characters.
Beck is a story about Arbiter Beck who was mentioned in The Price of Faith, but only briefly during one of Thanquil's memories. She has a starring role in Best Laid Plans and I wanted to give her a swashbuckling pirate adventure before that role begins so the short story brings her right up to where Where Loyalties Lie starts.
Q] The Best Laid Plans duology features a storyline and characters who weren’t quite major players in previous trilogy except one pirate who seems to be everywhere. What was your reasoning for this change in characters and world location?
RJB: Well I love pirates almost as much as I love witch hunters so I figured I should write a book about them.
The wheel keeps turning and there's more to the world than the wilds. I wanted to give a view of a different, but equally as dangerous and gritty, part of the world and the events that transpire in Best Laid Plans will fit into the larger story I'm telling. Some of the major players from TTtB will return, although in bit parts, but for the most part it's a fresh new cast.
Q] I loved the old-school map approach to the Bound Folio cover. Can you talk us through as how the cover came to be?
RJB: Well I had little to do with it to begin with. Shawn King (a true wizard of design) and Joe Martin came up with the concept. It just so happened that around the same time (with a little help from yourself, Mihir) I had a map of First Earth commissioned. Joe asked me about it and asked if we could use it on the cover.
I'm a big fan of the overall result and especially some of the little details folk might miss on a casual peruse, such as the inclusion of the holy symbol of the Inquisition on the back cover.
Q] Joe Martin and Shawn King have been responsible for some truly gorgeous covers which have been better than many traditional publishers. How does it feel to have them in your corner and give your books that extra edge?
RJB: It's great. I like to think of Shawn as the Gandalf of cover design, he's a true wizard. I've used him for my own self-published series It Takes a Thief... as well and I'll happily use him for any more I produce. I honestly can't recommend him enough.
Joe's a bit of a visionary, I think. I spout some insane ramblings at him and he disappears for a while, coming back a while later with exactly what I imagined. I don't know how he does it, but I'm glad he does it.
Q] What should readers expect from both these books?
RJB: Sex, violence, blood, a hint of magic, plenty of rogues, betrayal, huge battles, and rum.
RJB: Well I had little to do with it to begin with. Shawn King (a true wizard of design) and Joe Martin came up with the concept. It just so happened that around the same time (with a little help from yourself, Mihir) I had a map of First Earth commissioned. Joe asked me about it and asked if we could use it on the cover.
I'm a big fan of the overall result and especially some of the little details folk might miss on a casual peruse, such as the inclusion of the holy symbol of the Inquisition on the back cover.
Q] Joe Martin and Shawn King have been responsible for some truly gorgeous covers which have been better than many traditional publishers. How does it feel to have them in your corner and give your books that extra edge?
RJB: It's great. I like to think of Shawn as the Gandalf of cover design, he's a true wizard. I've used him for my own self-published series It Takes a Thief... as well and I'll happily use him for any more I produce. I honestly can't recommend him enough.
Joe's a bit of a visionary, I think. I spout some insane ramblings at him and he disappears for a while, coming back a while later with exactly what I imagined. I don't know how he does it, but I'm glad he does it.
Q] What should readers expect from both these books?
RJB: Sex, violence, blood, a hint of magic, plenty of rogues, betrayal, huge battles, and rum.
Q] With Where Loyalies Lie, the cover artist is Alex Raspad and features a very visually evocative scene. What were your inputs with regards to this cover?
RJB: Joe asked me what I would like to see on the cover. I'm more of a fan of scenes and vistas on covers, rather than character art. I said I'd like to see the scene from the very first chapter of Where Loyalties Lie on the cover. Drake Morrass on his ship, staring out towards a pirate town in flames. Joe exploded with excitement and a few months later we have that first scene. Alex did a fantastic job and I couldn't be happier.
Q] What can you tell us about the sequel to Where Loyalties Lie? Is there a name or blurb that you can exclusively reveal to us?
RJB: I can tell you it's called The Fifth Empire of Man and it's a rip-roaring, swashbuckling, piratical adventure of a fantasy tale.
Q] Thank you very much for your time Rob, what are you currently writing and any parting words for our readers?
RJB: Thanks very much for having me again.
I'm currently writing the second in my It Takes a Thief... series and it's called It Takes a Thief to Start a Fire. I'm hoping to have it finished, polished, and released sometime this year.
RJB: Joe asked me what I would like to see on the cover. I'm more of a fan of scenes and vistas on covers, rather than character art. I said I'd like to see the scene from the very first chapter of Where Loyalties Lie on the cover. Drake Morrass on his ship, staring out towards a pirate town in flames. Joe exploded with excitement and a few months later we have that first scene. Alex did a fantastic job and I couldn't be happier.
Q] What can you tell us about the sequel to Where Loyalties Lie? Is there a name or blurb that you can exclusively reveal to us?
RJB: I can tell you it's called The Fifth Empire of Man and it's a rip-roaring, swashbuckling, piratical adventure of a fantasy tale.
Q] Thank you very much for your time Rob, what are you currently writing and any parting words for our readers?
RJB: Thanks very much for having me again.
I'm currently writing the second in my It Takes a Thief... series and it's called It Takes a Thief to Start a Fire. I'm hoping to have it finished, polished, and released sometime this year.
Visit Gwenda Bond's Official Website Here
OVERVIEW: Lois Lane is
starting a new life in Metropolis. An Army brat, Lois has lived all over—and
seen all kinds of things. (Some of them defy explanation, like the
near-disaster she witnessed in Kansas in the middle of one night.) But now her
family is putting down roots in the big city, and Lois is determined to fit in.
Stay quiet. Fly straight. As soon as she steps into her new high school,
though, she can see it won’t be that easy. A group known as the Warheads is
making life miserable for another girl at school. They’re messing with her
mind, somehow, via the high-tech immersive videogame they all play. Not cool.
Armed with her wit and her new snazzy job as a reporter, Lois has her sights
set on solving this mystery. But sometimes it’s all a bit much. Thank goodness
for her maybe-more-than-a friend, a guy she knows only by his screenname,
SmallvilleGuy.
FORMAT: Fallout: Lois Lane 1 is the first in
a proposed YA series that is inspired by the Superman comics. The novel
contains a mix of mystery, action, and science fiction.
Fallout stands at 304 pages. It was published May 1, 2015 by
Switch Press.
ANALYSIS: Not every book has to be intense or super serious
to be good. Fallout, the first novel in the Lois Lane YA series by
Gwenda Bond, is an example of this type of book. It is fast paced, filled with
mystery, unique, and packed with loveable characters.
Before going further, it is important to note that this is a
story about Lois Lane.
Superman/Clark Kent is a subtle background character, but ultimately this is Lois Lane's time to shine. Most of the
appearances by Superman (it isn't really said to be Superman, but it is a
character that goes by the online screenname of SmallvilleGuy, so one can
assume) happen through brief interactions on the computer or even for a few
moments in a virtual reality game.
Those looking for more Superman and Lois Lane interactions will be disappointed, but if you take the
book for what it is worth – a Lois Lane
story. You won't be disappointed. But don't give up hope. There are hints that
there could be more Superman/Lois Lane
interactions in the future, as more books are brought into the series.
The two biggest highlights of Fallout happen to be the
mystery surrounding the novel and Lois
Lane's relationships with her fellow classmates and friends. The mystery
was appropriate for the novel. It had a very Metropolis feel to it, which made
it not only believable, but fun to read. Most of the mystery surrounds a
virtual reality game, which might not be enjoyable to some readers. Personally,
I found the virtual reality game parts believable and easy to follow, but some
individuals who aren't familiar with this concept or who really don't like
video games may not find it enjoyable.
Lois Lane's
relationships with her classmates and friends are another huge plus for this
novel. It was amazing to see how Lois
Lane developed friendships with a wide variety of classmates. Fallout
starts with Lois Lane being the new kid in town, and it was a real joy to see
how she integrated herself not only into the Daily Planet, but into the
day-to-day lives of her classmates. It was also a joy to see her as a strong protagonist that is working to help out her friends in need.
Overall, Fallout was an enjoyable, fun read.
The mystery aspect kept me involved and I really felt a connection to the
characters – in particular Lois Lane.
I am not 100% certain die-hard fans of Superman will fall in love with it –
after all these are beloved characters and while I feel it does it justice, I
am sure there is plenty for people to find fault with. But I think it is a
great novel for those who are looking for something a little different or for
those who want to take a peek into a new side of Lois Lane. I am eagerly
awaiting the second novel in this series.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

























