Blog Archive

View My Stats
Tuesday, October 26, 2010

"Surface Detail" by Iain M Banks (Reviewed by Liviu Suciu)

Official Iain Banks Website
Iain Banks at Wikipedia
Order "Surface Detail" HERE
Read FBC Review of 'Transition"

INTRODUCTION: Iain M. Banks' early Culture books, "Use of Weapons", "Consider Phlebas" and "The Player of Games" as well as the standalone "Against a Dark Background" are among my top sff books of all time, with "Use of Weapons" (which I hope to review by year-end) still at #1 after 18 years since my first read and many re-reads in the meantime.

Last year's Transition was my number 1 sff novel of the year and this year Surface Detail will be most likely #1 sff of the year. Actually as structure goes, Transition was a pretty complex novel that required at least one reread for full appreciation, while Surface Detail is straightforward, though of course rereading it brings a fuller appreciation.

Surface Detail is also a Culture novel, the best since the early three and the first in which the global vision of the Culture as part of a well developed galactic community that started in Excession and Look to Windward, while being explicitly articulated in Matter, pays off big time.

I have seen before this attempt to proceed from relatively local adventure novels like the first three Culture books, to having a fully developed coherent "big picture" framework as in Matter and Surface Detail and it is not easy, but when it succeeds, it does big-time.

Because beyond being a very entertaining novel, Surface Detail is much more, an articulated vision of an Universe that while purely materialistic as far as its inhabitants know, allows the major goodies associated with traditional religion: souls, afterlife, though of course logically it has some of its drawbacks like Hell(s). All of course was implied from the first Culture novel (Consider Phlebas), but here and in Matter the edifice hinted before is explicitly built.

FORMAT/CLASSIFICATION: Surface Detail stands at about 630 pages divided into twenty nine chapters, the usual IM Banks "what happened later with the characters" coda and a tongue-in-cheek epilogue that was hinted already in chapter two; I considered the possibility slightly far-fetched at the time, though there was a general "you know, it actually could be" feeling there. About what, well read the book to find out...

Surface Detail has several threads with all kinds of POV's: humans in the extended Culture sense like Ledejde - the "ingenue" decided on justice at all costs, even if it's inconvenient for the great and the good like the mighty Culture itself, Vateuil, "the ultimate warrior", Veppers, "the businessman from hell" - not quite literally, but close and Yime, "the Culture agent", non-human quadrepds "Pavuleans" Prin and Chay who take a literal journey in (the Pavulean) Hell and the "elfin" Legislator-Admiral Bettlescroy-Bisspe-Blispin III and of course the Culture Ships/Minds of which the The Abominator-class picket ship Falling Outside The Normal Moral Constraints and its bad boy avatar Demeisen take over the novel alongside Veppers.

Surface Detail is readable perfectly well on its own though a familiarity with the rest of the Culture novels only adds to its enjoyment.

OVERVIEW/ANALYSIS: The main idea of Surface Detail can be summarized simply: the laws of the Universe allow mind-states aka "materialistic souls" and any sufficiently advanced civilization can build a virtual afterlife since physical immortality in the Real is still undesirable due to issues like finiteness of space and resources. Some of course build Heavens, but some build Hells too...

Of course many of the most advanced (stage 7 and 8) civilizations object to the existence of Hells and the Culture is the most powerful of such, but unfortunately some events recounted in "Look to Windward" made it recuse itself from the debate for a while now. When the Pro-Hell and Anti-Hell forces decide to fight a virtual war - "The War in Heaven for the fate of the Hells" - to decide the issue for ever, the Culture (officially) stands on the sideline which gives an unexpected edge to the Pro-Hell side. And of course like all virtual contests, the result needs to be accepted by both parties since after all there is the Real where the war may otherwise spill with potentially catastrophic consequences.

While not directly involved with the war - except for Vateuil whose career as AntiHell grunt-to-marshal is recounted in his thread - all the characters above will nonetheless play an important role in its context and resolution.

I will let the three characters that dominate the novel speak for themselves:


“All those years, all those times I tried to run away, the one thing nobody ever asked me was where I might be running to.” She smiled a small, thin smile at the avatar, who looked surprised now. “If they had asked,” Lededje told her, “I might even have told them: I was running away to the Culture, because I’d heard they’d escaped the tyranny of money and individual power, and that all people were equal here, men and women alike, with no riches or poverty to put one person above or beneath another.” “But now you’re here?” Sensia offered, sounding sad. “But now I’m here I find Joiler Veppers is still deferred to because he is a rich and powerful man.”

Veppers (full quote here):

There was nothing worse, Veppers thought, than a loser who’d made it. It was just part of the way things worked – part of the complexity of life, he supposed – that sometimes somebody who absolutely deserved nothing more than to be one of the down-trodden, the oppressed, the dregs of society, lucked out into a position of wealth, power and admiration. ..... Still, at least individual losers were quite obviously statistical freaks. You could allow for that, you could tolerate that, albeit with gritted teeth. What he would not have believed was that you could find an entire society – an entire civilization– of losers who’d made it. And the Culture was exactly that.


“What, this?” he said, looking down at the ash-dark burn on his skin as Lededje stared at it, openly aghast. “Don’t worry; I don’t feel a thing.” He laughed. “The idiot inside here does though.” He tapped the side of his head, smiled again. “Poor fool won some sort of competition to replace a ship’s avatar for a hundred days or a year or something similar. No control over either body or ship whatsoever, obviously, but the full experience in other respects – sensations, for example. I’m told he practically came in his pants when he learned an up-to-date warship had volunteered to accept his offer of body host.” The smile became broader, more of a grin. “Obviously not the most zealous student of ship psychology, then. So,” Demeisen said, holding up his hand with the splinted finger and studying it, “I torment the poor fool.”

This is not say that the rest of the cast, especially Vateuil, Yime, Prin and Chay do not have important complementary roles but for me those three elevated the novel beyond all recent Culture novels which lacked precisely that: powerful, larger than life characters and here we have Veppers and Demeisen, while Ledejde is the most sympathetic Banksian character in a while for her quiet determination.

I talked about world building and sense of wonder in the introduction, while the coming together of the various threads is handled very well but I would like to add that there are so many great touches that I could fill two pages talking about them and those give Surface Detail a very rich texture. The novel has a lot of humor and I found myself laughing out loud at quite a few scenes, with the quotes above just a small sample.

If there is one negative is that the whole is somewhat less than the sum of the parts in the sense that each thread is very engrossing and with lots of specific goodies - the Pavulean Hell, the virtual War, the Unfallen Bulbitian and the Tsungarial Disk have each their goodies so to speak, in addition to the awesome stuff in the threads following Veppers, Ledejde and Falling Outside The Normal Moral Constraints/Demeisen - but the main story is quite straightforward. So in a sense you could look at Surface Detail as a core-story with beautiful ornate wrappings which one enjoys more in themselves than as part of a larger tapestry.

But that does not matter since Surface Detail (A++) is as good as speculative fiction on a large scale and about "big issues" gets from all points of view: great writing, powerful characters, coherent and detailed world building and just sheer sense of wonder and inventiveness. If you want to experience the best that sf has to offer these days and understand why written sf is still such a vital part of the "landscape of imagination", Surface Detail is the one 2010 novel for you. And the book has the added bonus that you can start exploring IM Banks' wonderful Culture universe just by reading it, even if you have not read previous Culture novels.


Peta said...

Iain M Banks is one of my "insta-buy" authors and this latest Culture book is one of my all time favourites of his. Which is saying a lot.

Definitely one for the Best of 2010 list!

Liviu said...

For me too :) I remember in the mid 90's (before Amazon...) asking the local booksellers if they can get a copy of his latest book from the UK at a reasonable price.

Now we are lucky that his work (as M which is understandable since his non-M is very British and that is hit-or-miss here and with me for that matter) caught up here in the US too and it is released more or less simultaneously in the big markets

Mimouille said...

I am a huge fan of Banks too, but have recently been disappointed by Against a Dark Background and matter, which are not at the level of Use of Weapons, Player of Games of Excession. Anyhow I plan to read Transitions and Surface Detail, hoping he will come back to his former grace...not that he has ever really lost it, just a little low maybe.

Liviu said...

Actually i liked ADB and i thought Lady Sharrow a great character on par with Horza and Zakalwe, while Ledejde here is more like Gurgeh - though the ending needs the extra page epilogue that is availble online but has not been printed as far as I know even in newer editions.

Matter was pretty good for 2/3 - I liked all that galactic structure that was being established - but I though the last 1/3 rushed badly

For me The Algebraist was disappointing since it promised a lot and had great moments only to...; if you read the book you will probably see what I mean, otherwise would not want to spoil it

Transition is different - in the UK it was published without the M though it has a Multiverse setting; has its flaws and sometimes it gets too clever for its own good, but overall I thought it excellent and even mind bending with all the threads circling back and intersecting

shaneo52 said...

Another great review, Liviu. I especially dig one of your reviews when it's a fav of yours. lol
I know you've told me before, but kinda forget, Consider Phlebas would be the best starting point with The Culture novels?

Liviu said...

Thanks for the kind words; I would say that any of the first three (UoW, CP, TPoG) will do; technically Consider Phlebas is the earliest chronologically and sets the Idiran war as the base of the timeline, but the catch is this has the POV of an enemy of the Culture

Use of Weapons is from a Culture mercenary POV with great secondary characters a Culture agent/handler and a super-drone, while The Player of games is the only one of the three from a Culture "citizen" POV and the only one that takes place even partially inside the Culture properly - the other two have scenes on Orbitals or Culture Ships but sort of "in passing"

shaneo52 said...

Thanks for that, Liviu. I guess UoW shouldn't be first as being the best loved. I'm gonna have to find a copy of CB.

Liviu said...

today they are easy to find in bookstores, libraries, online stores since Orbit is pushing IMB hard here too

I was lucky and i discovered them in my library system in the early 90's - the UK editions of all things - and I kept them on and off as much as I could, while of course when online book ordering from the UK appeared in the mid-90's those were the first books I got and i still have the UK editions (blue/white-black with the small spaceship cover for CP, purplish with the chair in front for UoW)

shaneo52 said...

My library only had Look to Winward, so I picked it up. You think it's a decent place to start, Liviu? It's a big, cool new library, but the book selection is not the best. lol They did tell me you can fill out a card and they borrow them from other libraries.

Liviu said...

Look to Windward is a novel that takes place on an Orbital (the main Culture fixed abodes since it is not a planetary civilization with large population on their AI Ships and the rest on Orbitals) but has main characters from different civilizations - an ambassador from their former Homondan enemies in the Idiran war who cut their losses and made peace once the Culture starting crushing the Idirans after the many atrocities against it in the first years of war that the Idirans thought would break the Culture's will - one such atrocity is memorialized in this book 800 years later when the light from it arrives at the Orbital in cause - and a Celgrian composer in exile; works as a standalone

I am curious what you think since for me it had some great stuff but lacked the larger than life characters of earlier books or the grandeur of Matter (despite its last 1/3 that was badly rushed, Matter has its moments no question) and Surface Detail

shaneo52 said...

Thanks again, Liviu. I'm gonna try to really get rolling with it, and I'll sure let you know.

Ron Buckmire said...

I loved Matte but have despised all thr other Banksian Culture books I have tried (Excession, Look To Windward, Use of Weapons)

Should I read Surface Detail?

Liviu said...

This has a lot of Matter feel in the sense of the world building, many societies, epicness, so hard to say, but I would at least browse it from a library, bookstore...

EFS said...

Guess what? I listened to Surface Details audiobook thanks to the rating you gave here. And I absolutely love it. peter Kenny is one darn good narrator - to match a darn good SFF author.
Thank you.

Liviu said...

Happy you are enjoying IM Banks and the audio narrator and thank you for your kind words.

Bill said...

I just started it and really like it. I suppose I should've waited until I finished it but I was looking form some info on the novel and came across your blog by accident. Nice review and great blog. Thanks, Bill


Click Here To Order “In The Shadow of Their Dying” by Anna Smith Spark & Michael R. FLetcher
Order HERE


Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE


Click Here To Order “Miss  Percy's” by Quenby Olson!!!
Order HERE


Click Here To Order “The True Bastards” by Jonathan French!!!
Order HERE


Click Here To Order “Rumble In Woodhollow” by Jonathan Pembroke!!!
Order HERE


Click Here To Order “The Starless Crown” by James Rollins!!!
Order HERE