Blog Archive

View My Stats
Showing posts with label spfbo. Show all posts
Showing posts with label spfbo. Show all posts
Thursday, March 26, 2026

SPFBO 11 - The Fifth Update

 


Friday, March 6, 2026

SPFBO XI - The Third Update (Mihir's Batch)

 



Wednesday, December 31, 2025

SPFBO Champions' League Has a Winner + Analysis of the results





SPFBO Champions' League has found its winner. The Sword of Kaigen took the first place by a comfortable margin. Using a simple Borda-style aggregation (1st = 10 pts … 10th = 1 pt) the results were as follows:
  1. The Sword of Kaigen (89/100)
  2. Orconomics (77/100)
  3. By Blood, By Salt (73/100)
  4. Small Miracles (61/100)
  5. The Lost War (54/100)
  6. The Thief Who Pulled on Trouble’s Braids (48/100)
  7. Murder at Spindle Manor (45/100)
  8. Gray Bastards (43/100)
  9. Where Loyalties Lie (33/100)
  10. Reign & Ruin (29/100)
Here are the score results each finalist got (yearly SPFBO are rated) in the year they won:
  1. The Grey Bastards 8.65
  2. The Sword of Kaigen 8.65
  3. Orconomics 8.65
  4. Small Miracles 8.65
  5. The Lost War 8.35
  6. Where Loyalties Lie 8.10
  7. The Thief Who Pulled on Trouble's Braids 8.00
  8. Murder at Spindle Manor 7.85
  9. Reign & Ruin 7.70
  10. By Blood, By Salt 7.70

As you see, the results don't align very well. Let's play with data and try to get some insights.

The Sword of Kaigen never placed dead last and appeared in the top 2 for 5 judges. It’s also one of only two books (Kaigen and By Blood, By Salt) that multiple judges ranked #1. Crucially, it avoids the “love it / hate it” split that drags down other entries. While it's not universally considered best, it's almost universally respected.

It seems the real race was for second place, where Orconomics beat By Blood, By Salt. Orconomics rarely won outright but almost never crashed. It was rarely anyone’s favorite, but almost never disliked and lived comfortably in the 2-6 range. 

By Blood, By Salt peaked higher (more #1s) but also hit several bottom placements, which hurted its aggregate. In other words, polarization hurted it. It was the most divisive pick with multiple #1s and multiple bottom-3 placements. Judges either connected hard or bounced off completely.

Speaking of polarization, it hurted more books: 

  • Reign & Ruin: regularly bottom 3, almost never top 3.
  • Where Loyalties Lie: multiple 10th-place finishes killed its chances despite some mid-tier love.
  • Gray Bastards: scattered placements with no strong center of gravity.
  • Meanwhile, Small Miracles benefited from mid-to-high consistency, landing a solid 4th without dominating anyone’s list.
  • The Thief Who Pulled on Trouble’s Braids won outright for some judges, but crushed near the bottom for others. Clearly, it hit some judges' preferences hard, but lacked broader appeal.

I found it fascinating that historical high scores don't align with the results of Champions' League. Four books tied at 8.65, yet they aged very differently. Now, it's good to emphasize that SPFBO Champions' League asks different question than any SPFBO finals. SPFBO scoring tries to answer the question  “How good is this?” whereas ranking asks “Would you pick this over that?”. With that in mind, it's still fun to try to answer this question.

Gray Bastards scored 8.65 historically, got a deal from Orbit and was traditionally published. And yet, it dropped to 8th in the Champions' League. There are many reasons, but I think the most important one is that SPFBO began in dark fantasy/grimdark-adjacent circles, and it shows. The first few winners were on the darker side of the fantasy. With time and new judges with a wide variety of tastes, the scores in the finals generally dropped and it became trickier to find a clear winner. Gray Bastards didn't got worse, but the audience and its tastes changed. The same is true for Where Loyalties Lie. 

By Blood, By Salt's final results is the most striking reversal: despite lowest historical score for SPFBO winner (7.70) it won 3rd place in Champions' League. And frankly, I have no explanation for this except for the fact that it may appeal to more craft-focused and detail oriented readers but irk those craving more action, here and now (that was my case). Objectively, it's a well-written book and, clearly, many readers adore it. 

Anyway, it seems that early SPFBO scoring rewarded excellence within a narrow subgenre and technical success at executing a specific and rather dark vibe. With time we saw the shift of preference toward cross-genre literacy, emotional accessibility and structural clarity.

If SPFBO winners were decided by collective critical consensus, The Sword of Kaigen still wins. And while I know there are readers who don't understand its phenomenon, they're clearly in the minority. With almost 90 000 GR ratings (still growing) The Sword of Kaigen is one of the most successful fantasy-adjacent books of the last decade.
Thursday, August 28, 2025

SPFBO Champions League Review:: Orconomics by J. Zachary Pike

 

Book links: AmazonGoodreads

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: J. Zachary Pike was once a basement-dwelling fantasy gamer, but over time he metamorphosed into a basement-dwelling fantasy writer. By day Zack is a web professional and creative-for-hire, but at night he returns to his lair to create books, films, and illustrations that meld fantasy elements with offbeat humor. A New Englander by birth and by temperament, Zack writes strangely funny fiction on the seacoast of New Hampshire.


Published: November 28, 2012 by Michael McClung Length: 362 pages Formats: audiobook, ebook, paperback Literary awards: SPFBO Award for Best Fantasy Book  Series The Dark Profit Saga

ŁUKASZ

Some reviewers have compares Orconomics to Pratchett novels. A bold statement if you ask me. As a fan of satires, I needed to experience and verify it myself. And I liked it.

It’s funny and uplifting but also serious and sad in some places, as every good satire should be.

On the world of Arth, adventuring is the industry that drives the economy. Groups of battle-hardened warriors hunt and kill Monsters and Shadowkin (Orcs, Goblins, Kobolds) and claim their hoards. These loots are bought and sold by corporate interests to plunder funds long before the hero’s guild attacks. You’ll easily see similarities to Goldman Sachs in Goldson Baggs operations.

The story follows Gorm Ingerson - a fallen dwarven hero whose hero’s license has been revoked. His clan disowned him, and he lives as a rogue. One of funds forcibly recruits Gorm to undertake an impossible quest with a team of similar fallen heroes. If he succeeds, he may win back the fame and fortune he lost so long ago.

His new team includes colourful and fun cast of characters– a goblin squire (who brings a lot of comic relief), clumsy and naïve prophet of a mad goddess, an elf warrior addicted to alcohol and drugs (healing potions in the book), two mages who are at each other's throats, a thief who claims to be a bard (even though he can’t really sing) and a warrior seeking his own death. They start the quest to find Elven Marbles. As we follow the story, the plot gets a little more complicated and nuanced.

I always appreciate a well-plotted and solid high fantasy tale with humour woven into the plot and the world. The world building mixed seamlessly into the story impressed me. The characterization doesn’t disappoint - even characters that seem very archetypical get significant development by the book’s end. The pacing is just right. It speeds up and slows down in all the right places.

The humour made me laugh. Obviously, no author should be compared to Sir Terry Pratchett - simply because no one stands a chance. In no way is this book on par with Pratchett’s novels. It is, though, a superb fantasy satire.

Thanks to mostly uplifting tone, Orconomics works as a well-deserved rest from dark books in which characters you love die, become evil or destroyed. On the other hand, it’s not all sunshine and roses. After finishing the book I’m impressed by Pike’s skilful blend of humour and tragedy. I mourn one of characters. Every good satire needs to contain a level of tragedy and Orconomics delivers both.

The ending of the book set ups for the sequel I will definitely read once I sort out my reading schedule.

MIHIR

Orconomics by J. Zachary Pike is one of my favourite books to have come out of SPFBO. Zack Pike’s debut was just a fascinating mix of epic fantasy tropes, satire & some brilliant but biting commentary on the foibles of unbridled capitalism.

“Gorm was a veteran of waking up in a strange place with a surplus of questions and a shortfall of memories.”

The main plot begins with Gorm Ingerson, a disgraced dwarven ex-hero who has long tried to run from his shameful past. Things have been rough for him for a few years but he’s finally been given a chance to redeem himself.  Soon a motley band is formed with Gorm, a goblin, an elf named Kaita and a scribe named Niln.  The team is later joined by a couple of mages who are semi-mortal enemies and hilarious with their bickering. The plot follows up it’s the normal fantasy trope of an epic journey and it’s herein where the author plays his first trick.

J. Zachary Pike lulls the reader while giving us a very characteristic and trope-filled story but the worldbuilding and story details are what make the story so unique. Firstly this is a world wherein adventuring and all the other details have been presented in a very financially-oriented way. The author does a brilliant job in setting up the reader with all the details of how this fantasy world operates. From quests wherein villages pay to have their surroundings cleared up to adventurers having to pay for their own upgrades. Imagine a fantasy world run by Mckinsey consultants & Disney’s accountants, this in a nutshell is a such a world. While there is a fun vibe to the story, but as a reader you can see the veneer of avarice beneath the trappings of it all. 

Even though this book is more than a decade old, its message about greed, corporate avarice and the dangers facing humans are just as true now as they when it was published. This book’s message is quite grim and kudos to the author for writing such a darkly brilliant story within a fun, satire mold. The story while following all the known Tolkienistic tropes, quite cleverly subverts them. I enjoyed this aspect and the humour within is of the sly kind which had me chuckling all throughout. 

The book has some truly dark aspects to it from character backgrounds to the rigid societal structure to the financial burden that’s yoked to most of the creatures. The author has however folded humour as much as possible so the dark aspects while significant don’t overpower the story. This way the main plot stays funny & satirical all the way till the end. 

I wouldn’t be lying if I say Orconomics is one of the most brilliant written stories to come out of the indie fantasy genre, however it wouldn’t be entirely accurate. The truth is Orconomics is one of the most brilliant stories to ever come out of the SFF genre. Give it a read and then read the sequels too (as the trilogy is complete). This way you can truly appreciate one of the best fantasy trilogies to have been gifted to us readers. 


SPFBO CHAMPIONS' LEAGUE RATING FOR NOW

1. Orconomics by J. Zachary pike
2. Where Loyalties Lie by Rob J. Hayes
3. The Thief Who Pulled on Trouble's Braids by Michael McClung
4. By Blood, By Salt by J.L. Odom

Wednesday, September 18, 2024

The Sword of Kaigen & Where Loyalties Lie - Special Editions Interview with Bryce O'Connor (interviewed by Mihir Wanchoo)

 


SPFBO has a special place in our hearts. Mark Lawrence's creation has cast a special spotlight on indie fantasy and self-published authors. Since its inception from 2015, we have had nine titles that have been declared SPFBO Champions.


The campaign was launched on September 3rd 2024, and it was fully funded in 6 mins. As of right now, its sitting at over $335k (3350% success rate). So today, we are happy to have the head of Wraithmarked, Bryce O'Connor, to talk a little bit about the project and whet your appetites.  
Tuesday, August 6, 2024

SPFBO X: The Third Diminution & Semifinalist Update (by Mihir Wanchoo

 


Saturday, June 17, 2023

SPFBO 9 (2023) Interesting Titles Spotlight Part I

 


Over the past, few years, with the start of every SPFBO edition. We have been raising a spotlight on a few of participating titles that caught our eyes. The books we highlight within today's and tomorrow's posts have caught our interest due to their blurbs, their covers, as well as potential plots. Some we have read, and reviewed, and hence are on this list.
 
We would like to state that this list is IN NO WAY an indicator of our choices (or the other judges) going forward in the contest. However, simply lists titles that we (at FBC) are INTRIGUED by and WOULD like to read (time & fate permitting). 
 
Therefore, without further ado, here is part 1 of the noteworthy titles (in random order):

Friday, May 19, 2023

SPFBO 9 Introduction Post - meet the Fantasy Book Critic Team + Top 3 covers




We're excited to announce we'll be participating in SPFBO for the ninth time. WooHoo! This year, we will have five judges on board and we're happy to welcome two new ones: Esmay and Chels. Here is a brief introduction to all of us involved in the contest:
Saturday, April 29, 2023

SPFBO 8 Has a Winner - Small Miracles by Olivia Atwater


Official Author Website

Order Small Miracles over HERE
Sunday, August 7, 2022

SPFBO 8: The Fifth Winnowing (Mihir's Batch)

 



 This year is the 8th edition of this wonderful competition and also our 8th time participating in it. It’s my pleasure to be able to review our last mini-lot. The books in my lot have been a wide variety across the fantasy spectrum.  I also had the unique distinction of having the biggest book (in terms of page count for this SPFBO edition) in my lot of six titles.
Wednesday, June 1, 2022

Spotlight: SPFBO 8 (2022) Intriguing Titles Part I

 


Tuesday, April 19, 2022

SPFBO: Interview with Becky M. (interviewed by Mihir Wanchoo)

 


Today I'm so glad to do a different kind of interview. Today I'm interviewing one of the SPFBO Judges from SPFBO 2021/ SPFBO 7. Becky M is a booktuber situated in the UK and is a lover of Sci-fi, Fantasy, Horror, Apocalypse, Dystopia and a big Stephen King fan. This was the first year of her judging in this contest and to add to this, she had possibly one of the toughest groups to judge. I thought it would be great to glean her insights as a debutant and being only the second booktuber judge in the past seven editions. 

So read ahead to get to know Becky and find out what she thinks...
Sunday, October 31, 2021

SPFBO 7 (Self-Published Fantasy Blog-Off) finalists and our approach


As avid fantasy readers, we love discovering new voices and hidden gemsSPFBO contest gives us such a possibility and we’re thrilled to participate in it for the seventh time. The first stage of the contest has just ended.

Monday, June 28, 2021

SPFBO: Interview with Alex S. Bradshaw, the author of Windborn


ABOUT ALEX: Alex grew up in Kent in the UK and spent much of his childhood hiding away and reading a book (seriously, he used to hide under the table and read when the other kids were playing).

He’s always been a fan of myths and legends, epic stories in general, and of course… dinosaurs. It came as no surprise to anyone that he went on to study Classics and Ancient History at university.

Now, Alex works in publishing and writes fantasy stories.

Find Alex online: WebsiteTwitter

Friday, May 21, 2021

SPFBO 7 Introduction Post - meet the team



FBC will have the pleasure to participate in the SPFBO for the seventh time. This time we'll have four judges involved in choosing our SPFBO champion. We're happy to welcome two new judges this year :) Here’s a bit of information on all of us:

Thursday, May 13, 2021

Q&A with M.L. Wang - the Winner of SPFBO 5



ABOUT M.L.: Hi! I’m M. L. Wang, author, martial artist, and weird recluse currently hiding somewhere in Wisconsin with my maroon-bellied parakeet, Sulu. I enjoy gruesome nature documentaries and long walks in circles around my room.

My published books include The Sword of Kaigen, Theonite: Planet Adyn, and Theonite: Orbit (series discontinued) and my ongoing serials include Gunpowder Magnolia, Seven Forsaken, and Sazuma.

Find M.L. online: Website, Patreon, Amazon, Goodreads, Newsletter

Thursday, April 15, 2021

SPFBO Finalist: The Lost War by Justin Lee Anderson review



Order The Lost War over HERE

About Justin: Justin was a professional writer and editor for 15 years before his debut novel, Carpet Diem, was published in 2015. He wrote restaurant and theatre reviews, edited magazines about football and trucks, published books about fishing and golf, wrote business articles and animation scripts, and spent four years as the writer, editor and photographer for an Edinburgh guide book.

Justin now writes full-time and is a partner in his own publishing company. He also writes scripts with his wife Juliet, who he met through the BBC Last Laugh scriptwriting competition.
Tuesday, April 13, 2021

SPFBO: Interview with Justin Lee Anderson






Order The Lost War over HERE(USA) or HERE(UK)

About Justin: Justin was a professional writer and editor for 15 years before his debut novel, Carpet Diem, was published in 2015. He wrote restaurant and theatre reviews, edited magazines about football and trucks, published books about fishing and golf, wrote business articles and animation scripts, and spent four years as the writer, editor and photographer for an Edinburgh guide book.

Justin now writes full-time and is a partner in his own publishing company. He also writes scripts with his wife Juliet, who he met through the BBC Last Laugh scriptwriting competition.
Sunday, March 28, 2021

SPFBO Finalist: Darkness Forged by Matt Larkin review



Friday, March 12, 2021

SPFBO Finalist: The Fall of Erlon by Robert H. Fleming (reviewed by Adam, Lukasz & Mihir)



Order The Fall Of Erlon over here USA / UK

FBC's Must Reads

FBC's Critically Underrated Reads

NOTEWORTHY RELEASES

 Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE

NOTEWORTHY RELEASES

 Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE

NOTEWORTHY RELEASES

 Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE

NOTEWORTHY RELEASES

 Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE

NOTEWORTHY RELEASES

 Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE

NOTEWORTHY RELEASES

 Click Here To Order “Barnaby The Wanderer” by Raymond St. Elmo
Order HERE